So much so that even Mark Mahaney, considered the top Internet analyst, titled a note to investors about the new service with a joke about it: "YouTube Red (No, Not Red Tube)."
(For the record, Mahaney thinks it's a good thing, but unlikely to make a lot of money in the short term.)
The similarities in the names (and in their respective URLs) could cause a lot of consumer confusion and awkward web surfing experiences.
Mahaney wasn't the only one who noticed the similarity:
this seems uncomfortably close to "Red Tube" https://t.co/167gdYVJss
- ?_? (@MikeIsaac) October 21, 2015
I can imagine someone being caught on RedTube and be like "oh man I meant to type in YouTube Red. Whoops"
- Molly (@Foxtrot44) October 21, 2015
When I heard "YouTube Red," I made the mental association with "RedTube," and I realized Google has (yet again) not thought this through.
- Nash (@Nash076) October 21, 2015
The name "RedTube" itself is already uncomfortably close to "YouTube." The addition of "Red" definitely brings the association home.