scorecard
  1. Home
  2. Politics
  3. Congress
  4. This is Supreme Court pick Merrick Garland's most famous vote

This is Supreme Court pick Merrick Garland's most famous vote

This is Supreme Court pick Merrick Garland's most famous vote
Politics2 min read

Merrick Garland

AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais

Merrick Garland.

Supreme Court nominee Merrick Garland's most famous vote involved what's considered one of the most important cases involving gun rights.

Garland, the chief judge of the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit, wanted the entire appeals court to reconsider a decision that had invalidated a handgun ban in Washington DC.

In doing so, Garland called for an "en banc" review of the DC Circuit's 2007 ruling that invalidated the handgun ban in Parker v. District of Columbia made by a three-judge panel Garland was not a part of.

The case, which would become known as District of Columbia v. Heller at the Supreme Court level, determined whether the handgun ban was constitutional under the Second Amendment.

Garland's vote called for a review of the his court's ruling, which invalidated the handgun ban. All 10 judges would have been a part of that decision.

But that request was rejected by a 6-4 vote by the court.

He did not take a formal position on the case's merits, however.

At the Supreme Court level one year later, in what was one of late Justice Antonin Scalia's most prominent majority opinions, the ruling of the appeals court was upheld.

The Supreme Court's ruling, which was a 5-4 decision, was based on an interpretation that the Second Amendment guarantees the right of gun ownership for private citizens, and not just for instances of necessary militia service.

Because Garland called for a review of the DC Circuit Court's ruling, even though he took no official position on the case, gun-rights advocates have slammed him for supposedly being pro-gun control.

On Wednesday, Garland was nominated by US President Barack Obama for the Supreme Court seat vacated by Scalia's recent death.

READ MORE ARTICLES ON


Advertisement

Advertisement