New CDC study offers the strongest evidence yet that COVID-19 can spread in airplanes
- A study published by the CDC found that asymptomatic COVID-19 carriers could spread the coronavirus on flights.
- The study found that on a flight with 290 passengers, one passenger appeared to catch the novel coronavirus from one of six asymptomatic carriers.
- The researchers said the study showed that wearing masks aboard flights was crucial to preventing the virus from spreading — along with hand hygiene, disinfecting surfaces, and working to limit contact during boarding and deplaning.
A new study published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found evidence that asymptomatic carriers could transmit the novel coronavirus to others on airplanes.
The study, published in the peer-reviewed CDC journal Emerging Infectious Diseases, was conducted by researchers in Korea led by Dr. Sung Hwan Bae and was based on an evacuation flight from Milan to Seoul, South Korea, in late March.
Before boarding, medical workers examined the 310 people scheduled to fly; 11 people who showed symptoms did not board the plane. Every passenger was given an N95 mask, and staff members followed strict infection-control procedures at the airport and in the air overseen by the Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. When the flight landed, the 299 passengers were quarantined by the government for two weeks and regularly tested for COVID-19.
Six passengers, who were asymptomatic, tested positive at the start of the quarantine. At the end of the quarantine, one passenger tested positive after previously testing negative.
That passenger was sitting three rows ahead of asymptomatic carriers and had worn her N95 throughout the flight, except to eat and use the lavatory. The asymptomatic carriers used the same lavatory during the flight.
Eighteen crew members and Korea CDC staff were also quarantined. All tested negative throughout the study.
Because of the strict infection control and post-flight quarantine, the researchers concluded that the newly infected patient had most likely caught the virus during the trip. A validation study looking at a second flight found the same outcome, with three asymptomatic patients most likely infecting one other passenger.
What's less clear is how, exactly, the virus was transmitted. High-efficiency particulate-arresting filters on aircraft, which remove microbes from recirculating air aboard planes, make airborne transmission difficult between seated passengers, the researchers said. That most likely contributed to the fact that only one passenger became infected; having every passenger wear an N95 respirator presumably also surely helped.
That makes it likely that transmission resulted from touching a contaminated surface or during boarding, disembarkation, or while walking in the aisles.
"Further attention is warranted to reduce the transmission of COVID-19 on aircraft," the researchers wrote. "Our results suggest that stringent global regulations for the prevention of COVID-19 transmission on aircraft can prevent public health emergencies."
Airlines have developed a variety of methods to mitigate the risk of COVID-19 transmission on flights as they try to instill public confidence and encourage people to return to flying.
Every major US airline requires passengers to wear masks while aboard. Some, including Delta, are blocking middle seats to facilitate social distancing. All have implemented new cleaning and disinfection regimens.
The study suggests that there's room for improvement, however, especially as asymptomatic passengers can contaminate surfaces during flights or may not cooperate with mask requirements.
The researchers offered three suggestions to mitigate risk: "First, masks should be worn during the flight. Second, because contact with contaminated surfaces increases the risk for transmission of SARS-CoV-2 among passengers, hand hygiene is necessary to prevent infections. Third, physical distance should be maintained before boarding and after disembarking from the aircraft."