I tried everyday bike shorts from Aerie and Everlane, and the best pair is worth the extra $8

I must admit that when the bike shorts trend started rising in 2019, I wasn't a fan. I have bigger thighs and a butt that I typically don't like to draw more attention to, and the idea of wearing a pair of shorts that would accentuate both of those things turned me off.

But my thoughts on the trend changed when I got my hands on the $30 Aerie Real Me Wrap Bike Shorts, which were sold out at the time of writing. According to the product description, the Aerie bike short was designed with a "four-way stretch, light support, and a V waistband with crossover details for a more flattering fit."

At first glance, the waistband might not seem like much, but the design feature is actually extremely slimming and doesn't feel too tight around my stomach. The extra fabric on the sides also provide even more coverage.

I absolutely love wearing these shorts to lounge around; they are super comfortable and provide a decent amount of coverage. However, the shorts also tend to ride up, which is why I always avoid wearing them outside of the house. I know the fact that they ride up around my thighs would annoy me while I'm running errands or out on a bike ride.

In June, Everlane launched the $38 Perform Bike Short, a cut-off version of its best-selling leggings.

According to the product description, the Perform Bike Short features "an extra-high waist, minimal seams, an inside pocket, and lightweight compression with technical sweat-wicking properties."

For months now, I have been searching for the perfect bike shorts that won't ride up long enough for me to feel comfortable wearing them out and about — and I had high hopes for the Everlane pair.

Everlane has been around since 2010, and it took me 10 years to finally buy something from the Meghan Markle-approved company.

Since I was new to the brand, I looked over the size guide to figure out what I should order. When it comes to bottoms, I usually wear between a 16 and 18, so I decided on an a XXL in the bike shorts. I thought it would be better to have them fit a bit large rather than be too tight.

Since it was my first time ordering from Everlane, I signed up for emails so I could get free shipping and a 10% discount on my order.

My final total came out to $34.20.

Since I chose economy shipping, I was fully expecting to wait four to seven business days to receive my order. That's why I was pleasantly surprised when I got an email letting me know that my item had shipped the very next day.

If you've read other reviews of mine, you know that I am a sucker for brands that use minimal packaging to ship their items.

The Everlane bike shorts came in a cardboard envelope that was thin enough to be folded up and placed in my recycling bin.

The bag featured a message explaining that it was made from recycled plastic. The envelope also didn't come with an extra paper receipt or excess materials, which I loved.

I have to admit that I was skeptical about these bike shorts because I didn't want to fall for the Everlane hype, but they blew me out of the water.

Thanks to the lightweight compression, the shorts hug your figure without feeling too tight. They're also super high-waisted, so I would feel comfortable wearing a crop top or a sports bra with these shorts because I wouldn't be showing off my stomach.

The best part? The shorts didn't ride up while I was walking. The first day I tried them on, I forgot I was wearing them when I took my dog for a walk. I was outside for about 30 minutes and not once did I find myself pulling them down.

As if learning that they don't ride up wasn't enough, realizing that the Everlane shorts have a pocket was what really convinced me that these are a better than my Aerie bottoms.

I have a pair of Calvin Klein leggings that also have a pocket, but it's so small that I can only fit my AirPods and keys. The pocket on these bike shorts is big enough to fit multiple cards, keys, headphones, and any small essentials you might need if you don't feel like carrying a purse or wallet.

The Aerie bike shorts are comfortable to lounge around the house in and I love the amount coverage I get from the V-shaped waistband, but the snug fit, length, and pocket design of the Everlane pair makes them a clear winner in my book.

There is an $8 difference in price between the two, but in my opinion, the Everlane shorts are worth the extra cost if you want a pair that won't ride up.

At the time of writing, the Everlane bike shorts were not available to ship until September, but they are worth the wait.

• Read more:
• I've owned a pair of Tommy John joggers for over a year, and they are the perfect work-from-home pants
• We tried Everlane's updated take on the classic utility jumpsuit — while the quality is a great value for $100, we had mixed feelings about the oversized fit
• I wear the popular Everlane Day Gloves at least 3 times a week — here's why I think they're the best flats you can buy
• Everlane's Slip Jumpsuit is breezy enough to keep you cool on warm days — but you'll want to order one size down