I shopped at Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel for holiday decorations, and there was a clear winner on the festive front

Terri PetersJan 15, 2024, 07:51 IST

Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel both offer high-end decor.Terri Peters

I shopped at Crate & Barrel and Pottery Barn to see which has better holiday decor.
Crate & Barrel had some high-quality-looking decorations, but Pottery Barn had more options.

Although I've shopped for affordable holiday decor at stores like Michael's and Dollar Tree this season, I was curious to see what more high-end retailers are up to.

While at a mall in Boca Raton, Florida, I visited Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel — two chains known for selling beautiful home decor with a decidedly high-end twist.

Here's how they compared.

Crate & Barrel's storefront wasn't overly decorated for the holidays.

The Crate & Barrel I visited wasn't really decked out with festive decor upon first glance. Terri Peters

Pottery Barn's storefront resembled a cozy Christmas living room.

The Pottery Barn location I visited had plenty of holiday flair. Terri Peters

Crate & Barrel's holiday tablescapes were simple and clean.

Holiday decorating varies greatly depending on personal taste.Terri Peters

Pottery Barn's table settings looked way more inviting to me.

Pottery Barn's tablescape was whimsical. Terri Peters

At Crate & Barrel, holiday pillows and throws seemed like an afterthought.

Those with a more minimalist style might like Crate & Barrel's couch display. Terri Peters

Pottery Barn's throw pillows and blankets were pure holiday magic.

Pottery Barn had festive pillows shaped like gingerbread people. Terri Peters

If you're looking for minimalist stockings, go to Crate & Barrel.

Crate & Barrel had simple stocking designs. Terri Peters

At Pottery Barn, there were even stockings for dogs.

Pottery Barn had some fun stocking options. Terri Peters

Crate & Barrel's ornament selection was OK.

Crate & Barrel had ornaments on display in bins. Terri Peters

Pottery Barn's ornaments were beautiful — and they happened to be on sale.

I could buy an ornament off of a tree at Pottery Barn. Terri Peters

There were far more holiday snacks at Crate & Barrel.

Crate & Barrel had some beautiful food gifts.Terri Peters

Pottery Barn had over-the-top holiday decor like Christmas bedding sets.

I added the festive bedding from Pottery Barn to my wish list. Terri Peters

There were lots of artificial Christmas trees for sale at Crate & Barrel.

Some pre-lit trees were available to buy from Crate & Barrel.Terri Peters

Based on my shopping trip, I'd choose Pottery Barn for a more festive experience.

As the holidays get closer, I'll most likely return to Pottery Barn to get a few pieces for my home. Terri Peters

See what it'll be like living on this 4-month cruise sailing around the world in 2026 with one of the world's largest cruise lines

Cookies on the Business Insider India website