scorecard
  1. Home
  2. life
  3. food
  4. news
  5. I tried chicken Parmesan recipes from Giada De Laurentiis, Alton Brown, and Ree Drummond, and the best one took 30 minutes

I tried chicken Parmesan recipes from Giada De Laurentiis, Alton Brown, and Ree Drummond, and the best one took 30 minutes

Meredith Schneider   

I tried chicken Parmesan recipes from Giada De Laurentiis, Alton Brown, and Ree Drummond, and the best one took 30 minutes
I found three celebrity chefs with different takes on chicken Parmesan. Meredith Schneider
  • I tried chicken Parmesan recipes from Giada De Laurentiis, Alton Brown, and Ree Drummond.
  • De Laurentiis took an unconventional approach, and Brown's recipe took the most effort to make.

Chicken Parmesan is an Italian-inspired dish traditionally made of breaded chicken covered in red sauce and cheese.

I've enjoyed the entrée many times, but I've never made it myself. So I was excited to try recipes from Ree Drummond, Giada De Laurentiis, and Alton Brown.

Here's how the celebrity-chef recipes stacked up.

De Laurentiis’ ingredient list was simple.

De Laurentiis’ ingredient list was simple.
I had no trouble gathering Giada De Laurentiis' simple chicken Parmesan ingredients.      Meredith Schneider

Though De Laurentiis' recipe took the second longest at one hour and 45 minutes, her ingredient list was the simplest of the three.

I gathered the chicken breasts, herbs and spices, and cheeses alongside the equally basic supplies for her homemade tomato sauce.

Her recipe is made with chicken cutlets.

Her recipe is made with chicken cutlets.
I made my own chicken cutlets from chicken breasts.      Meredith Schneider

The recipe called for chicken cutlets, which I couldn't find at my store.

Instead, I made cutlets out of full chicken breasts by cutting them down the center and flattening them.

De Laurentiis’ dish seems like a healthier option.

De Laurentiis’ dish seems like a healthier option.
This recipe didn't call for any breading.      Meredith Schneider

De Laurentiis has a "light" chicken Parmesan recipe, void of breading.

Instead, herb oil made of olive oil, rosemary, thyme, and Italian parsley is painted across both sides of the chicken.

I also added salt and fresh-ground black pepper to make a flavorful coating for each cutlet.

I cooked everything in an oven-proof skillet.

I cooked everything in an oven-proof skillet.
I seared and baked the chicken in a skillet.      Meredith Schneider

This particular recipe called for an oven-proof skillet to thoroughly cook the chicken.

I started by searing the cutlets in the pan over high heat for about two minutes on each side.

The tomato sauce was my last prep step, but I should've made it earlier.

The tomato sauce was my last prep step, but I should
I wish I made the sauce before prepping the chicken.      Meredith Schneider

De Laurentiis' simple tomato sauce is made using olive oil, a small onion, two cloves of garlic, a stalk of celery, a carrot, salt and pepper, two cans of crushed tomatoes, basil leaves, bay leaves, and unsalted butter.

But I used fresh, organic tomatoes instead of the canned option and opted for no butter.

I had to cook everything in a pot for an hour, so I'd recommend starting the sauce before digging into the chicken prep.

Once everything was ready, I covered the seared chicken with the sauce and cheese and baked it at 500 degrees Fahrenheit for about four minutes.

The chef's recipe seems best suited for those with special dietary needs.

The chef
I wasn't blown away by the chef's recipe, but I could see it coming in handy in some cases.      Meredith Schneider

Although it's much different from any chicken Parmesan I've had before, I think this recipe is perfect for those trying to eat a lighter diet.

It also seems like a great substitute for those avoiding gluten since it isn't breaded at all.

Brown's chicken Parmesan was the most complicated of the bunch.

Brown
I had to put in a lot of work to prep the chicken.      Meredith Schneider

Brown's version is all about precision and flavor. It takes a whopping two hours and 30 minutes and calls for "boneless, skinless chicken breasts, butterflied and pounded to ⅛-inch thick."

Because I purchased chicken breasts, I was responsible for cutting them into smaller pieces.

After butterflying them, the recipe said to cut them even further, effectively turning them into chicken strips.

I had to make some extra space in the fridge for this one.

I had to make some extra space in the fridge for this one.
Once I prepared the chicken, I had to be patient.      Meredith Schneider

After cutting the chicken into strips, I salted both sides and placed them in the refrigerator, covered, for 30 minutes.

When I was ready to bread the chicken, I made an assembly line.

When I was ready to bread the chicken, I made an assembly line.
I dredged with eggs, breadcrumbs, and flour.      Meredith Schneider

After refrigerating the chicken, I submerged each piece in flour, then into a pan of beaten eggs, and then directly into the breading.

Brown's recipe called for a breading made of breadcrumbs, salt-and-vinegar potato chips, oregano, parsley, and garlic powder. But I found Italian-blend breadcrumbs at Aldi with most of those seasonings, so I just added the crushed chips.

This is also when I prepped the sauce, which called for garlic cloves, a Parmesan rind, San Marzano tomatoes, red-pepper flakes, olive oil, salt, and anchovy filets.

There were multiple steps in Brown's cooking process.

There were multiple steps in Brown
Alton Brown's recipe was the most involved of the three.      Meredith Schneider

Brown's recipe required me to sauté each piece of breaded chicken for two minutes per side. I also had to pour some of the tomato sauce into a broiler-safe baking dish and broil it for two minutes.

Then I added the chicken, remaining sauce, and shredded fontina and mozzarella to the top before broiling for another 60 to 90 seconds.

The finished product was packed with flavor.

The finished product was packed with flavor.
I was a fan of Alton Brown's recipe.      Meredith Schneider

Although Brown's recipe took a lot of time and effort, I was pretty pleased with the results.

The extra flavors from the salt-and-vinegar chips and anchovies made it stand out.

Drummond’s recipe took much less time than the other two.

Drummond’s recipe took much less time than the other two.
Ree Drummond's chicken Parmesan ingredients.      Meredith Schneider

Drummond's recipe called for chicken tenders, which saved me some prep time and allowed the breading to touch more of the chicken's surfaces.

The chef also encouraged using a jar of premade marinara, making the total prep time only about 16 minutes.

For those who enjoy the quintessential chicken Parm experience, Drummond also includes angel-hair pasta in her recipe.

Parmesan and panko gave the chicken a unique texture.

Parmesan and panko gave the chicken a unique texture.
The panko added a nice flavor to the chicken.      Meredith Schneider

The meal came together quickly, so I started boiling the water for the pasta while I prepped the chicken.

To coat the tenders, I mixed ½ cup of panko breadcrumbs, ¼ cup of grated Parmesan, ⅛ cup of parsley, and some salt and pepper.

I dipped the chicken in egg whites before dropping it in the breading, as instructed.

I used the stove and the broiler for Drummond's recipe.

I used the stove and the broiler for Drummond
It didn't take long to throw everything together.      Meredith Schneider

Once everything was coated, I cooked the breaded chicken on the stove over medium-high heat for about three minutes per side.

Then I covered the tenders in tomato sauce and cheese and broiled everything until it was bubbly.

When it was ready, I poured everything directly over the cooked pasta.

I liked all three recipes, but Drummond’s was the crowd-pleaser.

I liked all three recipes, but Drummond’s was the crowd-pleaser.
Ree Drummond's recipe was everyone's favorite.      Meredith Schneider

My family taste-tested the plates with me, and there was a clear winner.

Drummond's crispy Parmesan-panko breading was delicious on a pile of warm pasta. It was everyone's favorite recipe, and the 16-minute prep time didn't hurt.

Brown's sauce was my favorite of the group — even if it was my first time cooking with anchovies — and the texture of the breaded chicken was exactly what I was looking for.

After this success, I might even add some flavored chips to my next breaded dish.

De Laurentiis' chicken Parmesan was my least favorite of the three, only because it didn't come with that heart-warming crunch that I've come to love from this meal. But I still think it'd be good in the right context.

Click to check out the other celebrity-chef recipes we've put head-to-head so far.

Advertisement