scorecardI tested Reese Witherspoon's and Martha Stewart's green-drink recipes to see which was best, and the winner was so refreshing I'd drink it every day
  1. Home
  2. life
  3. food
  4. news
  5. I tested Reese Witherspoon's and Martha Stewart's green-drink recipes to see which was best, and the winner was so refreshing I'd drink it every day

I tested Reese Witherspoon's and Martha Stewart's green-drink recipes to see which was best, and the winner was so refreshing I'd drink it every day

Debanjali Bose   

I tested Reese Witherspoon's and Martha Stewart's green-drink recipes to see which was best, and the winner was so refreshing I'd drink it every day
I tried Martha Stewart's and Reese Witherspoon's green-smoothie recipes and liked Stewart's version better.Cindy Ord/Getty Images/Reese Witherspoon/Instagram
  • I tried Martha Stewart's green juice and Reese Witherspoon's green smoothie to see which was best.
  • Both recipes were packed with leafy greens, fruits, and vegetables.
  • While both versions kept me full, Stewart's version had a distinct edge when it came to taste.

I wasn't much of a green juice fan - until I tried Martha Stewart's recipe a few months ago.

I wasn
Martha Stewart.      DANNY MOLOSHOK/Reuters

Stewart's organic morning green juice is regularly mentioned as a part of the skin-care routine that keeps her looking youthful.

In a December story about how the 79-year-old businesswoman gets Zoom-ready, Rory Satran of The Wall Street Journal wrote that Stewart starts every morning with her green juice.

Stewart's dermatologist also talked about the health and skin-care benefits of the beverage in Stewart's daily routine in a July interview with Elle.

While I only drank the juice for a few days for my trial and its effects on my skin weren't immediately apparent, I loved how the drink tasted and how it impacted my energy throughout the morning.

Stewart told the "Today" show hosts in January that she gets a lot of ingredients for the green juice right from her own farm.

A post shared by Martha Stewart (@marthastewart48)

Stewart has several farms — in New York and Maine — where she's been living during quarantine. 

As I don't have Stewart's farms (or her green thumb) to source my green-juice ingredients from, I made a trip to my local supermarket. The grocery haul ended up costing about $20.

The juice, true to its name, is packed with leafy greens, vegetables, and fruits.

The juice, true to its name, is packed with leafy greens, vegetables, and fruits.
The ingredients for Stewart's green juice recipe.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

During her January "Today" show appearance, Stewart gave a mini-tutorial on how to make the green juice and said that anything organic in your fridge can go into the juicer for this recipe, leaving plenty of room for variations and customizations that best suit your palate.

I decided to go with the classic version of the recipe published on marthastewart.com, which called for:

  • one green pear
  • two stalks of celery
  • two English cucumbers
  • one bunch of parsley
  • a one-inch piece of fresh ginger
  • two orange wedges, with the rind left on

In addition to not having Stewart's farm, I also didn't have a juicer. I had to come up with a workaround and use a blender and a sieve instead.

In addition to not having Stewart
In the absence of a juicer, I had to get creative with a blender.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

As I didn't have a juicer, I imagine my process to make the green juice was a little more labor-intensive than it usually is for Stewart.

The whole process with the blender and the sieve took around 30 minutes. I had overstuffed the blender initially and had to pause a few minutes in to take some of the ingredients out and then add them back in (in batches) after the bottom half had blended into a pulp.

While I didn't particularly enjoy the frothy look and taste of the smoothie the blender produced, once I ran the chunky mixture through a sieve, I was able to get the green juice I was trying to make.

My successful makeshift-juicing hack had resulted in a light-green liquid that barely had any unwanted bits of whole fruits or vegetables.

The juice has many ingredients that I don't particularly like - celery and cucumber, in particular - but when they all came together in the blender, I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the taste.

The juice has many ingredients that I don
Leftover celery that I tossed in the compost bin.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

The juice was refreshing and had a kick from the ginger. It also had an aftertaste of celery and some sweetness from the fruits.

I couldn't taste the cucumber and didn't mind that because I don't particularly enjoy eating it anyway.

I kept thinking about how good the juice would taste with some ice cubes on a hot summer day.

Aside from tasting great, the green juice kept me full for hours.

Aside from tasting great, the green juice kept me full for hours.
Stewart's juice packed a great flavor in addition to keeping me full all morning.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

The juice gave me a much-needed energy boost in the morning. If I had a juicer, I would absolutely add drinking this green juice to my morning routine.

After having a positive experience with Stewart's morning green juice recipe, I decided to give Reese Witherspoon's popular version of a green smoothie a spin.

After having a positive experience with Stewart
Reese Witherspoon is an actress and producer.      Christopher Polk / Getty Images

Like Stewart's recipe, Witherspoon's green smoothie also reportedly works wonders for your skin and keeps you full for hours.

Insider food reporter Anneta Konstantinides previously tried the smoothie recipe in July and wrote that Witherspoon started making this recipe every day for the past decade after actress Kerry Washington recommended it to her.

According to Washington, the smoothie, which was was originally inspired by celebrity nutritionist Kimberly Snyder's green smoothie, transformed her hair and skin.

I got to work making Witherspoon's smoothie first thing in the morning. Konstantinides wrote that Witherspoon usually makes a batch on the early side as well.

A post shared by Reese Witherspoon (@reesewitherspoon)

In a video shared on her Instagram page in May, Witherspoon gave her followers a step-by-step walkthrough on how to make the green smoothie. 

"I have this instead of breakfast. Around 10 or 11 in the morning, and then I'm not hungry at all until around 1 o'clock!" Witherspoon said in the video.

Much like Stewart's version, Witherspoon's recipe is also packed with leafy greens, vegetables, and fruits. It also has an additional ingredient I was excited about - coconut water.

Much like Stewart
The ingredients for Witherspoon's green smoothie recipe.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

The recipe called for:

  • 2 heads of romaine lettuce
  • ½ cup spinach
  • ½ cup coconut water
  • 1 whole banana
  • 1 whole apple
  • 1 whole pear
  • 1 whole lemon

As I was going through the ingredient list (which totaled about $16), it started to make sense why the smoothie keeps Witherspoon full all morning. It is packed with a large quantity of romaine lettuce as well as four different kinds of fruit.

I did, however, forget Witherspoon's "secret ingredient" — dancing. Oops!

Following Witherspoon's lead, I roughly chopped my ingredients, which only took about ten minutes.

Following Witherspoon
I chopped the ingredients into smaller pieces, but not too small.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

In addition to loving coconut water, I also love most kinds of fruit, so I was really excited to try the smoothie.

While I did have the right equipment - a blender - this time around, I still fell short when it came to the size of the blender.

While I did have the right equipment - a blender - this time around, I still fell short when it came to the size of the blender.
The blender after I'd only put in all the lettuce the recipe called for.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

The blender Witherspoon uses in her Instagram video appears bigger than the one I have at home with me.

My blender was already struggling with fitting everything inside by the time I had added just the lettuce, but I kept going.

The smoothie I whipped up looked very similar to Witherspoon's version in terms of the color and the texture.

The smoothie I whipped up looked very similar to Witherspoon
My version looked almost identical to Witherspoon's original smoothie.      Debanjali Bose/Insider/Reese Witherspoon/Instagram

I have to agree with what Witherspoon said while she poured her smoothie into a glass: It was, indeed, very pretty.

However, I didn't enjoy the overall taste even though I was a fan of the individual ingredients and how it all looked.

However, I didn
The recipe had a lot of lettuce.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

I enjoyed neither the taste nor the texture.

The smoothie was a little chunky in texture even after I ran it through the blender for quite a while.

When it came to taste, the smoothie was bitter, which I didn't love. And while I'm no culinary expert, I believe the two whole heads of romaine lettuce might have been the culprit. It was also a little tart in spite of all the pieces of fruit.

Konstantinides wrote in her story that Witherspoon's smoothie tasted a little better with a couple of ice cubes and I agree that it helped the drink.

Konstantinides wrote in her story that Witherspoon
The smoothie still tasted only okay with ice cubes.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

Adding ice cubes to the smoothie definitely made it more palatable.

When it came to Stewart's juice, you'll recall that I wanted to add a few ice cubes but the drink didn't particularly need it — unlike Witherspoon's smoothie, which definitely could use the help.

The smoothie did, however, keep me full for several hours, as promised by Witherspoon.

The smoothie did, however, keep me full for several hours, as promised by Witherspoon.
The fruits that went into the smoothie.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

I was full all morning, but maybe a little too full because the smoothie had so many fruits and vegetables.

I did also get a slight stomach ache around mid-morning, but it's unclear if it was because of the smoothie or something else I might have eaten the previous night.

Overall, I definitely prefer Stewart's green juice to Witherspoon's green smoothie.

Overall, I definitely prefer Stewart
I liked Stewart's green juice better.      Debanjali Bose/Insider

While they both kept me full for a while, Stewart's tasted better and was incredibly refreshing. I look forward to making it again, even without a proper juicer!

READ MORE ARTICLES ON

Advertisement