scorecardI tasted burritos from 3 iconic Colorado fast-food chains, and the winner was the cheapest and tasted the most complex
  1. Home
  2. life
  3. food
  4. news
  5. I tasted burritos from 3 iconic Colorado fast-food chains, and the winner was the cheapest and tasted the most complex

I tasted burritos from 3 iconic Colorado fast-food chains, and the winner was the cheapest and tasted the most complex

Monica Humphries   

I tasted burritos from 3 iconic Colorado fast-food chains, and the winner was the cheapest and tasted the most complex
Burritos from Chipotle, Illegal Pete's, and Qdoba were similar in size when Insider's author tried them.Monica Humphries/Insider
  • Popular fast-food burrito chains Chipotle, Qdoba, and Illegal Pete's were founded in Colorado.
  • After recently moving to the state, I wanted to compare veggie burritos from its three famous chains.

After moving to Denver, I decided to try and rank burritos from three fast-food chains originating in Colorado.

After moving to Denver, I decided to try and rank burritos from three fast-food chains originating in Colorado.
The author eats a veggie Qdoba burrito.      Monica Humphries/Insider

Qdoba Mexican Eats and Chipotle Mexican Grill — two of the country's most popular burrito chains — both got their start in Denver, Colorado.

After moving to Denver the summer, I learned there was another local fan favorite called Illegal Pete's.

The burrito company started in Boulder, Colorado, in 1995, and two decades later, there are a dozen Illegal Pete's chains sprinkled across Colorado and Arizona, according to the company's website.

I compared flour tortilla burritos filled with white rice, black beans, pinto beans, veggies, pico de gallo, hot salsa, cheese, sour cream, and guacamole from each location.

I compared flour tortilla burritos filled with white rice, black beans, pinto beans, veggies, pico de gallo, hot salsa, cheese, sour cream, and guacamole from each location.
Veggie burritos from fast-food chains originating in Colorado.      Monica Humphries/Insider

Since I don't eat meat, I opted for my go-to veggie burrito order from the three fast-food chains.

At around $8, Qdoba and Chipotle's veggie burritos cost about the same, and Illegal Pete's was the only chain that charged $2 more for guacamole.

At around $8, Qdoba and Chipotle
Qdoba and Chipotle's veggie burritos cost around $8, and the veggie burrito at Illegal Pete's cost around $10.      Monica Humphries/Insider

One of Qdoba's biggest appeals to me is that guacamole doesn't cost extra on any of their burritos. My total came out to $8.25 before tax.

At Chipotle, a veggie burrito without meat includes free guacamole and costs $7.65 before tax, the cheapest of the three burritos.

The veggie burrito at Illegal Pete's came out to $10.18 before tax since the guacamole cost an extra $2.19.

Each burrito looked and felt to be about the same size and heft.

Each burrito looked and felt to be about the same size and heft.
Burritos from Chipotle, Illegal Pete's, and Qdoba were similar in size when Insider's author tried them.      Monica Humphries/Insider

I typically think of Chipotle's burritos as being mammoth in size, so I was surprised that each burrito seemed to be about the same amount of food.

Qdoba's burrito looked the most appealing to me with the tortilla's toasty brown spots, but the flavor didn't hold up to the looks, in my opinion.

Qdoba
The author's burrito from Qdoba looked toasty on the outside.      Monica Humphries/Insider

Qdoba's burrito tasted too bland to me.

I thought the rice, beans, and veggies lacked any strong flavors, and the salsa didn't really make up for it.

I felt there was too much rice and not enough of the other fillings in my Qdoba burrito, which earned it third place in my ranking.

I felt there was too much rice and not enough of the other fillings in my Qdoba burrito, which earned it third place in my ranking.
A crosscut of the author's veggie burrito from Qdoba.      Monica Humphries/Insider

I had three consecutive bites of just rice while eating the burrito. Where were all the extra toppings? I never really found them.

But the tortilla, which was the thinnest of the three, was my favorite.

Without any standout flavors, though, I thought Qdoba's veggie burrito left a lot to be desired.

Illegal Pete's was the only chain that mixed its burrito's fillings before wrapping it up, which I thought was a nice touch.

Illegal Pete
The author's burrito from Illegal Pete's didn't have many toasty brown spots.      Monica Humphries/Insider

Thinking that the ingredients in my burrito were well combined, I expected to have a little bit of everything in each bite.

Unfortunately, my first few bites were just the tortilla.

Illegal Pete's tortilla was by far the thickest of the three, and by the time I finally got to the fillings, I was already starting to get full.

The burrito had the best salsas, in my opinion, but it got soggy too quickly for my liking, earning it second place in my ranking.

The burrito had the best salsas, in my opinion, but it got soggy too quickly for my liking, earning it second place in my ranking.
A crosscut of the author's veggie burrito from Illegal Pete's.      Monica Humphries/Insider

I was disappointed by how few veggies I found wrapped inside my Illegal Pete's burrito, but I thought the flavors were strong, which moved the burrito up in my ranking.

After I tried all three burritos, I came back to Illegal Pete's for a second taste. This time, though, the bottom of the tortilla was soggy, bumping it to second place out of the three chains.

I thought Chipotle's colorful veggies, bright salsa, and cilantro rice were familiar and as delicious as ever.

I thought Chipotle
The author's burrito from Chipotle looked slightly toasty on the outside.      Monica Humphries/Insider

Chipotle is my go-to stop for fast-food burritos, and I quickly learned why after trying each chains' burritos back-to-back.

While the Chipotle burrito was the messiest for me to eat, it had the most variety in flavors.

I noticed a smokey flavor coming from the hot salsa and grilled vegetables that neither Illegal Pete's nor Qdoba's burritos had.

That, combined with the bright flavor from the pico de gallo, created a variety of tastes that coated my entire mouth.

The burrito had the best flavor and texture, in my opinion, making it first place in my ranking.

The burrito had the best flavor and texture, in my opinion, making it first place in my ranking.
A crosscut of the author's veggie burrito from Chipotle.      Monica Humphries/Insider

I also noticed many more distinguishable textures inside Chipotle's burrito compared to the other two.

The fajita veggies were the crunchiest of the three chains', which paired well with the creaminess from the guacamole and sour cream.

Out of the three burritos, I thought Chipotle's had the most complex textures and tastes.

Overall, I thought Chipotle and Illegal Pete's offered the most flavorful veggie burritos. But Chipotle's burrito came out on top thanks to its price, texture, and flavor.

Overall, I thought Chipotle and Illegal Pete
By the end of the taste test, the author left little of the Chipotle burrito behind.      Monica Humphries/Insider

I don't think you can beat $8 for a smoky, creamy, and satisfyingly crunchy veggie burrito. Chipotle was — and will continue to be — my fast-food burrito chain of choice.

READ MORE ARTICLES ON

Advertisement