scorecardI ate at Via Carota, the NYC restaurant frequented by Taylor Swift and her famous posse. She's onto something — it's the perfect girls' night out spot.
  1. Home
  2. life
  3. food
  4. news
  5. I ate at Via Carota, the NYC restaurant frequented by Taylor Swift and her famous posse. She's onto something — it's the perfect girls' night out spot.

I ate at Via Carota, the NYC restaurant frequented by Taylor Swift and her famous posse. She's onto something it's the perfect girls' night out spot.

Jordan Parker Erb   

I ate at Via Carota, the NYC restaurant frequented by Taylor Swift and her famous posse. She's onto something — it's the perfect girls' night out spot.
Insider's reporter at Via Carota, a restaurant frequented by Taylor Swift.Jordan Parker Erb/Insider
  • Taylor Swift and Sophie Turner were recently spotted leaving Via Carota in New York City.
  • Swift is a regular at the Italian spot, often dining with other famous pals.

I know about a lot of things, but there's very little that I know about Taylor Swift.

I do know, however, that she recently dined at Via Carota in New York City with Sophie Turner — and as a journalist, I must give the people what they want: an inside look at one of the singer's fave restaurants.

Located in Manhattan's West Village, the Italian restaurant is just a short walk from Cornelia Street — the street perhaps best known for housing Swift's famous brick-faced apartment and for inspiring the song "Cornelia Street."

Being that Swift is something of a regular — she dined there with Jack Antonoff in September before a girl's night with Turner — Via Carota is notoriously hard to get into. Outlets like People warned interested fans that the wait could take hours to get seated at the West Village institution.

Considering that I headed there early on a Monday evening to snag a table for one — and can see why celebrities like Swift flock to the restaurant.

I arrived on a rainy Monday for an early dinner — right at 4:30 p.m. — to beat the lines.

I arrived on a rainy Monday for an early dinner — right at 4:30 p.m. — to beat the lines.
The dimly lit Via Carota.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

When I arrived, the restaurant's outdoor seating area was virtually empty, with just two tables seated at the time I arrived. Inside was slightly busier, with a few tables occupied, but I was seated as soon as I got there.

Settling in for my meal, I realized my early arrival was well-played. By 4:45 p.m., a line was forming in the entryway, threatening to flow out the door within minutes.

After scanning the menu, I asked what Taylor Swift typically likes to order, but no one knew.

After scanning the menu, I asked what Taylor Swift typically likes to order, but no one knew.
The menu at Via Carota.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

If I was going to live like Taylor Swift for an hour, I wanted to get the full experience and order what she likes to eat. Unfortunately, none of the waiters knew her typical order.

My waiter told me that since Swift typically goes for dinner, the daytime staff didn't know what the pop star likes to eat.

Instead, I ordered what I thought the world's preeminent pop artist would order: a light appetizer and some pasta.

Instead, I ordered what I thought the world
Insider's reporter chose an appetizer and an entree during her time at Via Carota.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

I don't know much about being a pop star, but I know that appetizers and pasta are irresistible, especially at a high-ranking Italian restaurant. So, I ordered what I thought Swift might like.

I chose the restaurant's heirloom tomatoes, which came with onions and basil, for a light bite before the main course: a cacio e pepe pasta dish.

The heirloom tomatoes were fresh and juicy but exceptionally salty.

The heirloom tomatoes were fresh and juicy but exceptionally salty.
Via Carota's heirloom tomatoes with basil, onions, and cucumbers.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

The tomatoes arrived quickly, within 15 minutes of ordering, and were light and tasty.

They tasted fresh and were well-complimented by basil, cucumbers, and onions sliced so thin they looked like angel hair pasta. They did, however, come topped with a noticeable amount of salt — so much that you could see the granules atop the dish when it was placed on the table.

While that's not necessarily a bad thing, in my opinion, it may be too much for some people.

The cacio e pepe was on par with other varieties I'd tasted before.

The cacio e pepe was on par with other varieties I
Cacio e pepe at Via Carota.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

Cacio e pepe, or cheese and pepper, has been flooding my social media recently — and because I imagine Swift is a TikTok girlie who's in touch with all things trending, I ordered the cheesy dish.

In my first bite, I thought the pasta tasted disappointingly similar to the noodles with melted butter and cheese I make when I'm too lazy to make an authentic dinner. But after thoroughly mixing the pasta and sauce, I was more impressed.

The light yet robust sauce was peppery without being overwhelming and packed a zing of lemon throughout. My last bite was far more impressive than my first.

For dessert, I treated myself to a slice of tiramisu.

For dessert, I treated myself to a slice of tiramisu.
Tiramisu at Via Carota.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

The respectably sized tiramisu was no better or worse than other versions of the dessert I've had in the past. It was sweet, squishy, and fluffy in all the right ways, but not necessarily something I'd seek out in the future.

Still, I'm a glutton for sweets, so I finished the whole thing.

Though I didn't see any stars during dinner, I can see why the restaurant is such a draw for A-listers.

Though I didn
Insider's reporter at Via Carota in Manhattan's West Village.      Jordan Parker Erb/Insider

Dimly lit and teeming with old-world charm, the restaurant is quaint and welcoming. It's cozy, like dining in someone's Italian villa. The staff were prompt and respectful but not overly warm; still, I can see why Swift frequents Via Carota with her high-profile pals.

In total, including tax and tip, my meal was $80. It's not something I can afford to splurge on every time I go out, but for a special occasion with my friends, I can see Via Carota being the place I choose to go.

My parting advice? Go for an early dinner or drink — or be prepared to wait in line.

Advertisement