REUTERS/Enrique Castro-Mendivil Delegates to the United Nations have finally returned home after a two-week-long exhausting slog toward an international agreement to curb greenhouse gas emissions and fight global climate change.
The conference was supposed to be a milestone in Earth's climate history - a chance to curb carbon output in time to avoid the worst effects of climate change.
Given all the high powered representatives at the meeting, though, it was a huge disappointment. There are at least two big problems with the draft as it is, according to environmental organizations and activists.
Here's what some key environmental players have had to say about the deal:
- The new agreement does not reflect the urgency of the climate crisis.
- Some good agreements - but no measures to ensure implementation.
- Least developed and vulnerable nations left out in the cold.
- Divestment is more important than ever.
- Global momentum for real solutions is stronger than ever and will keep on going.
REUTERS/ Mariana Bazo Eric Holthaus, a meteorologist who writes for Slate, published an opinion piece on Sunday decrying the weak language in the draft. He writes:
The wording of the Lima text, in combination with the fact that any global deal almost certainly won't have legal force (because the U.S. Congress would never ratify a legally-binding climate treaty), means that whatever comes out of Paris-the site of the next climate summit, in 2015-probably won't be a game-changer.
Samantha Smith, of the World Wildlife Fund, released a scathing statement Sunday on the climate agreement, which included the following criticism:
Governments crucially failed to agree on specific plans to cut emissions before 2020 that would have laid the groundwork for ending the fossil fuel era and accelerated the move toward renewable energy and increased energy efficiency.
The
Others took to social media to air their opinions. Here's some of what we found on Twitter:
Now governments try to justify why they accepted such a pathetically weak text. And the struggle continues. #COP20
- Brandon Wu (@brandoncwu) December 14, 2014
Incredibly weak outcome from #COP20 in Lima. Governments have a lot to answer for and a lot of lost ground to recover before Paris.
- Mark Lutes (@MarkLutes) December 14, 2014
End of #COP20, most tough decisions to slow #climatechange postponed to 2015 Paris conference. http://t.co/bCu7AitAHH via @reuters
- Casey (@Casey_McDermott) December 16, 2014
Over the next few months, we'll start to get a sense of how things will go at Paris as participating nations begin submitting their emissions reduction plans.
Paris will be the real test, the place where negotiators will use the Lima draft to hash out their final agreement - but if these activists have anything to say about it, there may not be much to look forward to.