scorecard
  1. Home
  2. Politics
  3. The SNP oppose Trident but that won't stop them doing a deal with Labour

The SNP oppose Trident but that won't stop them doing a deal with Labour

Tomas Hirst   

The SNP oppose Trident but that won't stop them doing a deal with Labour

Scottish Trident protest

REUTERS/Russell Cheyne

Demonstrators take part in a CND Scotland anti-trident rally in Glasgow, Scotland, April 4, 2015.

The Conservatives are claiming that Labour would trade plans to build four Vanguard-class submarines to carry Britain's Trident nuclear missiles for a deal with the SNP to put it into government.

There's only one problem with this strategy - Nicola Sturgeon already said that scrapping Trident is not a condition for a vote-by-vote deal.

In an interview with Sky News on Thursday the SNP leader said "any confidence-and-supply arrangement would require the non-renewal of Trident", comments that were seized upon as proof that any deal would require negotiations over Britain's nuclear deterrent. A confidence and supply arrangement is where a party commits to vote with a minority government on its budgets and rules out voting against it if a no confidence vote is called by the opposition.

Yet when asked about it directly by The Guardian last month Sturgeon she refused to rule out a deal even with Trident on the table. She said:

"We're unlikely to go into a formal coalition with Labour. It's more likely to be an arrangement where we would support Labour on an issue by issue basis. Under that arrangement there would be many things that we could agree on and that we would support, but we would not vote for Trident."

She was absolutely clear that while the SNP would not under any circumstances vote for Trident and couldn't agree to a formal confidence-and-supply arrangement with it included, the party would still be comfortable doing a deal with Labour that would allow Ed Miliband to push the existing nuclear deterrent programme forward providing he could get the votes from elsewhere.

Since the Times article, in which the claims were first made by defence secretary Michael Fallon, came out this morning the line has shifted to the number of submarines that Labour would build (will it be three or four?) suggesting, perhaps, that the Conservatives are aware that they may not be watertight.

Yet, if Sturgeon is true to her word, the only way that the Trident programme as a whole would be under threat under a Labour/SNP deal is if the Conservatives themselves vote against it.

So a deal could be done. The open question is whether a Labour government reliant on SNP votes would be able to get a budget through that included Trident spending. If not, then such an administration would have an even shorter shelf-life than most people expect.

Here's the clip in full:

READ MORE ARTICLES ON



Popular Right Now



Advertisement