The rise and fall of Subway, the world's largest fast-food chain

The first Subway was actually called Pete's Super Submarines.

Nuclear physicist Peter Buck and college student Fred DeLuca opened Pete's Super Submarines in 1965, in Bridgeport, Connecticut. On the first day, the shop sold 312 sandwiches, each costing less than $1.

In 1968, the two founders rebranded the shop and called it Subway, and by 1974 the company had 16 shops throughout Connecticut.

By 1981 Subway had 200 locations across the US, with 100 more opening the following year.

At the time, the chain was known for its BMT — marketed as the Biggest, Meatiest, and Tastiest sandwich — and its Snak, which eventually became the six-inch sandwich we know today.

It was relatively easy to buy a Subway franchise, so the company easily grew throughout the '80s and '90s.

Subway is one of the cheapest brands to franchise. It costs between $116,000 and $263,000 to open a Subway. For comparison, it costs between $1 million and $2.2 million to open a McDonald's.

As a result, Subway expanded quickly, both in the US and overseas.

Subway opened its 5,000th restaurant in 1990, as the company focused on opening franchises in non-traditional spaces.

Subway opened restaurants in gas stations, at truck stops, at rest areas, and even in convenience stores. Its "anywhere and everywhere" mentality allowed it to expand quickly.

In the '90s and early 2000s, weight and health became a priority, so Subway marketed itself as a healthier alternative.

Although Subway always marketed itself as a healthy fast-food option, the company really began to emphasize its health advantages when the country became increasingly diet-crazed. In 1997, Subway released a campaign that advertised its seven low-fat sandwiches and compared them to other fast-food chains' unhealthy burgers and tacos.

By tapping into American's priorities, Subway became the largest restaurant chain in terms of locations in the US, passing McDonald's in 2002.

At the same time, Subway released another health-focused campaign with Jared Fogle, who claimed to have lost over 200 pounds by eating Subway.

In 2000, Subway introduced the US to Jared Fogle, who said he used to weigh 425 pounds but lost over 200 of those pounds by eating Subway sandwiches. Fogle was often seen on commercials holding up his old pants, proving how much weight he had lost.

The campaign was so successful that sales rose 20% after the first commercial.

During the 2008 recession, finances became a priority among many US consumers, so Subway focused its marketing on the $5 footlong.

Riding off the success of Fogle's ads, Subway launched a new "$5 footlong" campaign with a catchy jingle. The campaign came in response to many US consumers' desire for cheaper food options. By 2011, the company's sales reached $11.5 billion.

But everything started to change in 2014. That year, Subway's sales started to drop as customers became unsatisfied.

In 2014, Subway's sales declined by 3%, and competition from chains like McDonald's, Jimmy John's, Potbelly, and Panera didn't help.

At the same time, Subway's large number of store locations suddenly became a problem.

Subway got too big, too fast. Instead of focusing on location, the company focused on restaurant count. As a result, restaurants opened within blocks of each other, creating competition within the same company.

"I feel their concerns 10 years ago was just opening up locations," a franchisee with two locations told Business Insider. Fred DeLuca, one of Subway's founders, "was obsessed with having the most locations, and he achieved it. We had people open up on all sides of us. That was definitely a problem."

Subway experienced a major setback in 2015 when Fogle, the former face of the company, pleaded guilty to having sex with minors and distributing and receiving child pornography.

He was sentenced to nearly 16 years in prison in December 2015.

Subway immediately cut ties with Fogle by deleting any mention of him on its site and social media accounts.

In 2016, Subway closed more stores than it opened for the first time in its history.

Sales dropped to $11.3 billion in 2016, which was down from $11.5 billion in 2015. In response, the company closed 359 locations worldwide.

The trend continued into 2018 when the company closed 1,108 Subway locations in the US.

At the beginning of 2018, the company said it expected to close 500 stores that year. It ended up closing more than it expected. Subway now has 24,008 locations in the US.

• Read more:
• The rise and fall of Payless ShoeSource
• 10 photos that show the glory days of Payless ShoeSource
• These haunting photos of the retail apocalypse reveal a new normal in America as Sears clings on after closing hundreds of stores