The Fed is quietly signaling that stocks are overvalued and a recession is almost certain, top economist David Rosenberg says
- Investors sent the Dow to a record high on Wednesday after the Fed signaled rate cuts were coming.
- But the Fed's new growth forecast points to overvalued stocks and a recession, David Rosenberg says.
Investors sent the Dow Jones Industrial Average to a record high on Wednesday after the Federal Reserve signaled that the inflation threat was fading and that it expected to cut interest rates three times in 2024. They may be celebrating too soon, David Rosenberg has warned.
The Fed chair, Jerome Powell, struck a positive tone after the central bank's latest meeting. He pointed to the pace of price growth slowing markedly in recent months, unemployment hovering at historic lows, and economic output proving resilient.
Yet Rosenberg, a veteran economist who's the president of Rosenberg Research, said in a pair of X posts on Wednesday that the Fed's latest growth projection suggested stocks were overpriced and a recession was virtually guaranteed.
The former chief North American economist at Merrill Lynch questioned why the stock market was pricing in a 10% rise in corporate earnings next year when the Fed only expected nominal economic growth of 3.8% in 2024.
A company's stock is typically valued at a multiple to its earnings per share, which tends to be correlated to GDP, as businesses produce goods and services that contribute to a country's output and typically generate more sales and profits when the economy is growing.
"There is no recession risk at all embedded in equity valuations," Rosenberg said in a research note on Thursday, emphasizing that he believed stock investors were too optimistic about what's ahead.
Rosenberg also cautioned on X that the Fed's forecast of slower GDP growth next year implied a 90% probability of recession. He explained that his team expected inflation to plummet below 1% next year, making 3.8% nominal growth "very difficult to achieve" and closer to 2% more realistic.
"From my lens, given what the monetary policy lags imply and the withdrawal of fiscal stimulus means for real GDP growth for 2024, we are likely talking about real growth of no better than +1.0% and quite possibly zero," he said in a note to clients.
"That is rare but not unprecedented: we saw this in 1949, 1954, 1958, 2008, and 2009 — all recessions," he said. "Maybe the odds are 100% instead of 90%."
"What was delayed in 2023 shall not be derailed in 2024," he added.
Rosenberg has been sounding the alarm on a stock-market crash and recession for years, going as far as comparing the current situation to the dot-com and housing bubbles. But stocks have surged this year, and the economy has proven surprisingly resilient, defying his dire predictions.