scorecardWe shopped at IKEA and Target to see which is a better place to buy inexpensive furniture. Here's the verdict.
  1. Home
  2. slideshows
  3. miscellaneous
  4. We shopped at IKEA and Target to see which is a better place to buy inexpensive furniture. Here's the verdict.

We shopped at IKEA and Target to see which is a better place to buy inexpensive furniture. Here's the verdict.

First we went to IKEA in Brooklyn.

We shopped at IKEA and Target to see which is a better place to buy inexpensive furniture. Here's the verdict.

One of the first things we saw in the store was a massive showroom of couches and armchairs. The chairs cost around $300, and couches are typically around $600.

One of the first things we saw in the store was a massive showroom of couches and armchairs. The chairs cost around $300, and couches are typically around $600.

It also sells bar stools that range in price from $60 to $150. The quality varied — some of the less expensive products didn't feel super sturdy.

It also sells bar stools that range in price from $60 to $150. The quality varied — some of the less expensive products didn

It also has smaller showrooms with shelves and display units. Assembly is required for most products, but IKEA has a partnership with TaskRabbit that you can use if you don't want to spend time putting everything together yourself.

It also has smaller showrooms with shelves and display units. Assembly is required for most products, but IKEA has a partnership with TaskRabbit that you can use if you don

Dressers and other small furniture items cost under $100.

Dressers and other small furniture items cost under $100.

A lot of the products that IKEA carries are very minimalistic and simple. The quality didn't seem to be great, but nothing was particularly expensive. These shelves cost $20 each.

A lot of the products that IKEA carries are very minimalistic and simple. The quality didn

Large bookcases cost under $40.

Large bookcases cost under $40.

Shelving units can be bought individually or in combination with one another. Combinations could cost as much as $600, but it was hard to tell how sturdy they were.

Shelving units can be bought individually or in combination with one another. Combinations could cost as much as $600, but it was hard to tell how sturdy they were.

On the lower level, I saw a marketplace that carried essentials besides furniture. Most of the kitchen products IKEA was selling were very basic, white-and-gray products. Everything cost under $10, and many things like utensils cost under $5.

On the lower level, I saw a marketplace that carried essentials besides furniture. Most of the kitchen products IKEA was selling were very basic, white-and-gray products. Everything cost under $10, and many things like utensils cost under $5.

Plates and bowls typically cost under $4 per plate or $25 for a set.

Plates and bowls typically cost under $4 per plate or $25 for a set.

IKEA has tons of storage boxes for under $20.

IKEA has tons of storage boxes for under $20.

The marketplace also carries rugs that range from $20 to about $100 ...

The marketplace also carries rugs that range from $20 to about $100 ...

... $2 towels ...

... $2 towels ...

... and pillows for only $20. The quality on everything seemed decent, but not great.

... and pillows for only $20. The quality on everything seemed decent, but not great.

Towards the exit were products like photo frames and decor. Small frames only cost $2 ...

Towards the exit were products like photo frames and decor. Small frames only cost $2 ...

... but larger prints cost up to $100.

... but larger prints cost up to $100.

IKEA's store credit card offers 5% back in rewards on each purchase. It also has a rewards program called IKEA Family that offers members monthly discounts, free coffee, food discounts, and perks like price protection and a purchase history to make re-ordering easier.

IKEA

IKEA has a ton to offer. Most of the products it carries are pretty basic, and prices are low on a majority of what it carries. The quality varies a lot, and assembly is required on almost everything. But one of the biggest perks is that IKEA has a partnership with Task Rabbit, so you don't have to put everything together yourself.

IKEA has a ton to offer. Most of the products it carries are pretty basic, and prices are low on a majority of what it carries. The quality varies a lot, and assembly is required on almost everything. But one of the biggest perks is that IKEA has a partnership with Task Rabbit, so you don

Next we went to Target in Jersey City, New Jersey.

Next we went to Target in Jersey City, New Jersey.

Even though Target may not be the first store that comes to mind for furniture, it actually has a lot of different home products to offer. But because it isn't a furniture store, it doesn't carry nearly as much as IKEA.

Even though Target may not be the first store that comes to mind for furniture, it actually has a lot of different home products to offer. But because it isn

At the Target we went to, there were no armchairs or couches. It did have a lot of bar stools like IKEA did, and the price range was about the same.

At the Target we went to, there were no armchairs or couches. It did have a lot of bar stools like IKEA did, and the price range was about the same.

It was hard to judge the quality because everything was kept in boxes.

It was hard to judge the quality because everything was kept in boxes.

Target's furniture is also pretty simple and minimalistic, like IKEA's. Assembly is required on most things, but Target does not have a partnership with TaskRabbit, so you'd have to assemble things yourself.

Target

Kitchen products generally cost more at Target. For example, spoons for cooking cost $2 each at IKEA, but $6 each at Target.

Kitchen products generally cost more at Target. For example, spoons for cooking cost $2 each at IKEA, but $6 each at Target.

Target's plates and bowls cost about the same as IKEA's.

Target

Target also has tons of storage boxes for under $20.

Target also has tons of storage boxes for under $20.

The rugs at Target cost between $50-130, which is more expensive than at IKEA, but the quality seemed to be about the same.

The rugs at Target cost between $50-130, which is more expensive than at IKEA, but the quality seemed to be about the same.

Towels were also more expensive for similar quality, costing $10 on average instead of $2.

Towels were also more expensive for similar quality, costing $10 on average instead of $2.

Pillows were about the same price ...

Pillows were about the same price ...

... but picture frames and decor were almost all slightly more expensive at Target.

... but picture frames and decor were almost all slightly more expensive at Target.

Target also has a rewards credit card that offers shoppers 5% off every time they use it. It also offers early access to promotions, two-day shipping, and extended returns.

Target also has a rewards credit card that offers shoppers 5% off every time they use it.  It also offers early access to promotions, two-day shipping, and extended returns.

Even though the products offered at IKEA and Target are similar styles and quality, IKEA had better prices on most products, and it offers TaskRabbit assembly services to make it easier on the shopper, making it the clear winner.

Even though the products offered at IKEA and Target are similar styles and quality, IKEA had better prices on most products, and it offers TaskRabbit assembly services to make it easier on the shopper, making it the clear winner.

Advertisement