We compared the top 5 wedding registries in the US including Amazon, Zola, and Target - here are all the pros and cons

Pros

• Number of physical locations: The chain has an impressive 1,550 physical locations, which means that for most people, it's fairly easy to make it into a location nearby and view your gift in person before deciding to buy.
• In-store consultations: Expert consultants can help you build your registry so you or your guests can hone in on the perfect gift.
• Return policy: You have a whole year to make all returns, both in store and online.

Cons

• Smaller selection.
• Less efficient delivery.
• The online shopping experience isn't quite as quick and seamless as other options.

Pros

• Number of physical locations: Similar to Bed Bath & Beyond, Target has a far-reaching 1,844 physical locations. Most people will have fairly convenient access to a nearby Target.
• Easy returns: If you print the registry at the store, you don't need to bring a receipt.
• Return policy: Similar to Bed Bath & Beyond, Target also has a one year return window, making returns, a huge sticking point for many, a bit easier.
• Familiarity and recognition: Your guests can kill multiple birds with one stone because they're already shopping at Target anyways, whether in-store or online.
• Group gifting: Any item over $100 automatically qualifies. Otherwise, you can manually change the price settings. When a group gift is funded, you will receive a Target eGiftCard in the amount funded to use to buy anything on the site.

Cons

• Option variety is not quite as wide as Amazon's selection, making it slightly less appealing, especially for couples who are seeking more eclectic gifts.
• Does not have Amazon Prime delivery and logistics.
• The new household goods selection is stronger in Bed Bath and Beyond.
• No in-store consultations or registry experts.

Pros

• Number of physical locations: While nowhere near the reach of Bed Bath & Beyond or Target, Crate & Barrel does have 90 physical locations nationwide.
• Exclusive products: Crate & Barrel's collection of housewares and furniture comes from worldwide collaborations with top artists, designers and local artisans. The items that you can find in C&B are most likely not available on any other registry.
• List maintenance: Like Amazon, the store maintains a list of who purchased which gift from your registry, so you can easily send out thank you messages afterwards.
• In-store registry events: Stores host frequent exclusive, in-store registry events with food and drinks where you can tour the store and meet with registry experts.

Cons

• While 90 physical locations isn't nothing, it's not guaranteed that your town will have a location nearby — a downside for those who prefer to shop in person.
• Short 90 day return window.
• You only can receive free shipping if your order is over $100.
• Returns also only convert into Crate & Barrel credits, which locks you into choosing your next item from Crate & Barrel (and limits the ability to get gifts back as cash, which couples are increasingly fond of doing).

Pros

• Add gifts from any website, not only Zola: Install the 'Add to Zola' extension in your browser for easy one-click shopping from your favorite stores like West Elm or Nordstrom.
• User interface and aesthetics: The design of the website makes for a pleasant shopping experience.
• Delivery time selection: So you're not overwhelmed by the constant packages arriving at your door, receive real-time notifications of when a gift has been purchased and decide whether you want that gift right away or if you'd rather wait.
• List maintenance: Like Amazon and Crate & Barrel, the store maintains a list of who purchased which gift from your registry, so you can easily send out thank you messages afterwards.
• Gift exchange policy: You can decide to keep the gift and have it shipped, or exchange it for something else. This way, you never receive an item you don't want, and you don't have to deal with physical returns.
• Ask for experiences and cash: Outside of products, you can request services like a Blue Apron subscription, Airbnb gift card, or location-specific experiences. You can also create cash funds for anything — your honeymoon, airfare, house down payment, even parts of the wedding itself like the cake.
• Group gifting: Enable this feature on any product and let guests contribute any amount or choose price increments. If the gift isn't 100% funded, receive whatever amount has been gifted to you.
• Free wedding website: Zola's service includes a free website, which integrates your registry. It offers more than 270 templates to customize.

Cons

• One physical showroom in New York City where you can browse gifts and get help from a Registry Advisor.
• Shipping costs apply for large gifts that require special handling.
• Less well-known than the other retailers.