The director of HBO's Andre the Giant documentary explains how he debunked some major myths and got Vince McMahon to cry

One of the most shocking moments of the documentary is toward the end when during an interview with WWE owner Vince McMahon be begins to choke up and hold back tears when talking about how much Andre meant to him and his company (despite the two having a falling out at the end of Andre's career).

Hehir said that wasn’t the first time McMahon, known for his tough guy swagger, showed a softer side in front of him.


“He got emotional when no cameras were there,” Hehir said. “The first meeting I had with him I mentioned that Andre had a really close relationship with his daughter and he got pretty emotional there.”

Hehir said that McMahon agreed to do a 45-minute interview for the movie and Hehir could come back later in production to shoot any follow-ups with him. The 45-minute shoot turned into a three-hour interview.

McMahon getting emotional on camera was hard to film, Hehir said.

“Vince seemed to be trying to keep it together and as an interviewer it's excruciating because your instinct is to turn the camera off," he said. "But you have a responsibility to the viewer to let them experience this feeling vicariously through the person who knows the subject well, so we included that in the film.”

For wrestling die hards the recollections by Hulk Hogan of the lead-up to his match with Andre at WrestleMania III are something special. One great detail is him explaining how he wrote out the entire match on a yellow legal pad McMahon gave him when McMahon asked the wrestler how he thought the match should go down. Hogan scripted the entire match, but left how it would end empty for Andre to decide. Andre didn’t reveal the ending until during the match, according to Hogan.


In the movie, while Hogan is telling the story, there are shots of yellow legal pad sheets with handwriting on them. Hehir said that’s really Hogan’s handwriting of the match.


“That yellow legal pad is crucial to the telling of that story,” he said. “But that has been long crumbled and thrown into the trash. Probably the night of the event. So for months I tried to get Hogan to recreate to the best of his recollection what he wrote down.”


Hehir interviewed Hogan for the movie in April of 2017. He said he finally got the pages from Hogan in the middle of December on the final day they could possibly get it into the movie before handing a finished version over to HBO.

“When we got it you could feel your heart beat opening the envelope,” Hehir said. “I told Hogan even if he could write a few lines we could shoot them really tight, he ended up writing all those pages you see in the shot — two single-spaced pages. And he wrote it as if he was in the moment, so if you freeze frame it you can see it says something like, ‘Don’t let Andre see this.’”


“Any of us could have written those pages and no one would know whose handwriting it was,” Hehir continued. “But I just thought it would be a cool wink to people who do know this world that they would recognize Hogan’s handwriting.”

“My crew would laugh if they heard you ask me this question because they know it makes me ill,” Hehir said with a laugh.

One of the most popular stories about Andre the Giant is that when he was 12 years old he was so big he couldn’t fit on the school bus, but it so happened that famed playwright Samuel Beckett lived down the road from him. Andre’s father helped build Beckett’s house. So the “Waiting for Godot” author would pick up Andre with his flatbed truck every morning and drop him off at school.

The story grew over time as Andre would tell it to friends, like “The Princess Bride” costar Cary Elwes, and it was even was made into an off-Broadway play.

Turns out none of it is true.

While Hehir was in Moliens, he asked one of Andre’s brothers about the Beckett story.

“Beckett's house is a few hundred yards down the road from Andre's childhood home, that is true,” he said. “The reality is there was no bus to school in that town. There was a two kilometer walk from Andre's house into the center of town, where the school house was, and all the kids in the village took that walk to and from school everyday. Andre's father had no hand in helping to build Samuel Beckett's house. Beckett had a truck and if he passed the kids he would stop and let them hop into the flatbed of his truck and he would drive them to or from school. But it wasn't singular to Andre and he had no special relationship with Andre any more than he did with any other child in that area. Andre's brother laughed at us when we told him what the legend is.”


Why didn’t Hehir debunk it in his movie?

“Do I want to bring you down this story only to pull the rug from under you?” he said. “I didn't want to waste anyone's time.”