scorecardThe best lip stains
  1. Home
  2. slideshows
  3. miscellaneous
  4. The best lip stains

The best lip stains

The best lip stain overall

The best lip stains

The best luxury lip stain

The best luxury lip stain
YSL Vinyl Cream Lip Stain has a comfortable mousse-like texture and a shiny finish, making it look and feel more like a balm than a stain.

High-end makeup can be overpriced for no good reason, but the YSL Vinyl Cream Lip Stain is unique and worth the price tag. This is a mousse-like formula with a slightly shiny finish that's very different from most lip stains. In fact, it acts more like a balm than a stain because of the finish and texture.

It goes on creamy, offers full-coverage color, and boasts a 10-hour wear-time, which is rare for any lip product with shine. The glossiness will start to fade a bit if you smack or lick your lips, but it'll still have a slight sheen to it. An angled, diamond-tipped applicator helps give you a crisp line with no extra lip liner required.

An Insider Picks editor who tested the lip stain said it was one of her favorites because it was moisturizing and didn't make her lips look pruney. The soft glossy finish also made her lips look more dimensional and plump, as opposed to watery stains that leave behind a wash of color but no shine.

It's also been featured as the top lip stain pick by Byrdie Beauty, whose editor writes, "For a lip stain, it boasts impressive coverage."

Pros: Slightly glossy finish, up to 10 hours of wear time, precise applicator

Cons: Expensive

The best drugstore lip stain

The best drugstore lip stain
The Revlon Balm Stain is an affordable and easy-to-use lip crayon available in eight wearable shades.

For an inexpensive and easy-to-use lip stain, look no further than the Revlon Balm Stain. These affordable lip crayons are easy to apply and comfortable to wear.

Available in eight wearable colors, these moisturizing balms are perfect for everyday wear. They contain what the brand calls a "Triple Butter Complex" of shea, mango, and coconut butters, making the formula feel more like a tinted lip balm that happens to contain long-lasting color.

The pointed chubby crayon makes it easy to apply without running over the lip line. You'll probably need to reapply these if you plan on eating and drinking a lot while you wear them, but they're much more pigmented than your typical balm, with far superior staying power.

The product has been recommended by experts at Byrdie, Harper's Bazaar, Elle, and StyleCraze. A writer at The Strategist even says it has been "my go-to lip product every single day for the last three years."

Pros: Lightweight, moisturizing, easy to apply, affordable

Cons: Only available in eight shades

The best multitasking lip stain

The best multitasking lip stain
The Benefit BeneTint Cheek & Lip Stain is a multi-use liquid lip and cheek stain that provides a long-wearing sheer finish.

One of the OG lip stains on the market, this little bottle of Benefit BeneTint Cheek & Lip Stain can be blended onto the lips and cheeks for a naturally flushed look.

The original BeneTint has been around for more than 15 years and it's still a versatile rosy shade that suits a variety of skin tones. The formula is quite sheer with a liquidy, slightly gel-like texture that blends like a dream and dries matte. You can definitely layer it up depending on the finish you want, but blend it out and let it dry down before adding more.

The nail polish brush-style applicator makes it easy to paint the tint onto your lips without overdrawing the line, or dot onto your cheeks before blending out with your fingertips. You can really control the amount of product you get by brushing on just a small layer at a time, which makes it great for building up more color. The formula will dry down after a few seconds to ensure staying power.

BeneTint also been featured on Byrdie, Elle, Harper's Bazaar, StyleCraze, and Rank and Style.

Pros: Can be used on cheeks and lips, blendable, nail polish-like applicator to easy to use

Cons: Expensive, only comes in one shade

The best stain-like lipstick

The best stain-like lipstick
Glossier Generation G is an ultra-sheer matte lipstick that wears like a stain, giving you a soft wash of color.

Although Glossier's Generation G is officially marketed as a lipstick, it behaves more like a stain in my experience and the subtle color stays put forever.

The color is buildable, low-maintenance, and long-lasting. There's no smudging and the fade-down is elegant — no patchy color, no weird ring around your lips. And the formula is so comfortable you'll forget you're wearing anything. This ultra-sheer, ultra-matte formula has no trace of gloss or shimmer.

Available in six shades, the range is paired-down to the essentials, including a red and a '90s-inspired brown. I personally love Cake, a terracotta peach, and Crush, a raspberry pink that gives you the perfect popsicle lip stain. All the shades are subtle but buildable, and they allow your natural lip color to show through.

This is my go-to everyday lip product. I find that I can comfortably wear and reapply these without drying out my lips, thanks to oils like sunflower, beeswax, and safflower. I do recommend applying lip balm first if your lips are easily chapped. The color has such great staying power that if I only apply once in the morning, I'll still see the color when I go to remove my makeup at night.

The product has been recommended by editors at Elle, Allure, and Byrdie, among other publications. WhoWhatWear's Mica Ricketts calls Gen G "one lip product I recommend above all others to my friends who don't do lipstick."

Pros: Very sheer and natural, easy to layer, colors fade nicely over time, long-wearing color

Cons: Can emphasize dry flakes if lips aren't moisturized

What else we considered

What else we considered
  • E.l.f. Aqua Beauty Radiant Gel Lip Tint: This is another Byrdie and StyleCraze favorite lip tint, but it's not as well-reviewed by shoppers as our top budget pick from Revlon and there are only three shades available.
  • Revlon Cushion Lip Tint: Another great pick from Revlon, but not quite as universally renowned as the Balm Stain featured in the top five. This lip stain uses a cushion applicator to gently pat on the nourishing, coconut oil-infused formula for a sheer, slightly glossy finish.
  • Dior Addict Lip Tattoo: This luxury pick is featured on a few lists of best lip stains, but it isn't as well-reviewed as our YSL pick. Some shoppers found the formula a bit drying, especially for the high price tag.

Check out our other makeup guides

Check out our other makeup guides
The best lipsticks

Lipstick colors span the rainbow from deep plum to classic red and even pastel yellow. Various finishes and formulas are available too — matte, sheer, hydrating, longwear, and more. No matter what color or finish you're looking for, these are the best lipsticks you can buy.

The best foundation

Foundation in the right color and formula can help make your skin look like you slept 18 hours and drank 10 gallons of water. But the paradox is finding that perfect foundation. These are the best foundations you can buy.

The best concealer

Finding the ideal concealer is a challenge, in part because everyone's definition of "the ideal concealer" is different. Some want full-coverage, others want something natural and undetectable. Or, maybe you want both in your collection to use for different occasions. These are the best concealers for any occasion.

The best bronzers

If you want a radiant, sun-kissed color all year round, or you're trying to maintain a post-vacation glow, bronzer should be a must-have product in your makeup arsenal. These are the best bronzers.

Advertisement