The best cold-brew coffee makers you can buy

The Toddy Cold Brew System has a long track record of providing a great balance of simplicity and flavor.

Cornell chemical engineer graduate Todd Simpson developed the Toddy Cold Brew System in 1964. The system includes a brewing container with handle, two reusable filters, a rubber stopper, a glass decanter with lid, a recipe guide, and instructions. The filters are designed to last for three months or up to 12 uses, whichever comes first.

The process for making cold-brew coffee is essentially the same as that of our top pick. The only difference is that the Toddy system does not have a separate water bowl. This may account for why many prefer the smoothness and flavor of the Filtron brewer. Still, many coffee bloggers who review coffee gear love the Toddy.

Seattle Coffee Gear recommends the Toddy Cold Brew System because of its design and ease of use. The reviewer found that a single filter did an excellent job of trapping bitter acids for up to a dozen uses and liked the smooth taste of the concentrate.

Coffee Review tested the Toddy, and while the reviewer appreciated the simplicity of the system and the quality of the concentrate it produced, the writer would have liked it if the system came with a lid to keep out oxidation, dust, and more. The reviewer also found that the filter was prone to clogging, but still recommended it as an affordable and dependable option.

More than 1,000 people have left positive reviews of the Toddy Cold Brew System on Amazon. One buyer had used his Toddy regularly for five years until one morning, the handle gave way and the whole setup crashed onto his floor — sending concentrate and broken glass all over the floor. Nonetheless, he still had positive things to say about the quality of the coffee.

Another buyer hooked up a vacuum pump to the Toddy to speed up the drip process, which tends to be slow otherwise.

Pros: Easy to use, produces smooth-tasting cold brew

Cons: Doesn't have a lid, long-term durability concerns

Buy the Toddy Cold Brew System on Amazon for $34.95 Buy the Toddy Cold Brew Coffee Maker System with Extra Filters and Rubber Stoppers Bundle on Amazon for $45.99 Buy the Toddy Filters (2-pack) on Amazon for $4.99 Buy the Toddy THMPF20 Paper Filter Bags (20-pack) on Amazon for $14.99

If you don't mind spending a little extra for style and convenience, the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker is the ideal brewer for your kitchen.

There are a few features that set the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker apart from the coffee makers we've looked at so far. First, there is a unique perforated "rainmaker" top that helps distribute the water evenly over the coffee grounds, which is key for optimal flavor extraction. Also, rather than using a stopper or plug at the bottom of the coffee bowl, there is a valve that is easy to turn on and off.

The OXO cold-brew maker features a fine, stainless steel mesh filter that you can reuse, though you may still want to use a paper filter for easier cleanup. The carafe is made of borosilicate glass, which is quite resilient since it does not expand or contract like normal glass. The carafe is shaped like an Erlenmeyer flask, which is sure to appeal to chemists. Lastly, this OXO gadget can produce up to 32 ounces of cold brew at a time.

Insider Picks Senior Editor Malarie Gokey uses the OXO cold-brew maker in her own kitchen every day during the hot summer months when hot coffee just isn't appealing. It's incredibly easy to use because you don't have to worry about any filters or small parts.

The simple design is incredibly smart. You just ensure that the release valve is locked, add the amount of coffee you want to use, pop the rainmaker top on, and pour the right amount of water over the grounds in a circular motion. The water will rain down on the grounds and get brewing.

In our tests, we let it brew for 12 to 24 hours, depending on the flavor we wanted. When it's done brewing, you just flip the release valve and watch the coffee pour down into the carafe. Perhaps best fo all, OXO includes a secure stopper for the top of the carafe, so you can just pop it on and put the entire carafe in the fridge.

The machine turned out excellent cold-brew every time we used it. It does take some trial and error to get the flavor you want, but OXO's guidelines give you a good idea of where to get started. We recommend experimenting with different kinds of coffee to see which flavors and strengths you like. We were particularly fond of a fruity Colombian blend a family friend gifted us because it almost tasted like chocolate milk when we made cold-brew with it.

The machine is remarkably easy to clean after, too. You just scoop the grounds into the trash and rinse it out. The OXO cold-brew machine makes brewing coffee an incredibly simple and effortless experience.

Other expert reviewers also rate the OXO machine highly. Wired, CNET, and The Wirecutter all recommend it. About 74% of the customer who reviewed the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker on Amazon gave it 4 or 5. stars.

One Amazon customer compared the OXO to the Toddy, which he used for a decade before trying out the OXO. Overall, he found the OXO brewer is superior because of the pouring valve, which allows him to pull a cup and let it brew a little bit longer. With the stopper of the Toddy, it's hard to "recork" it. Plus, you could potentially lose the stopper.

Pros: Stylish design, easy to store, uses a valve for pouring

Cons: Relatively expensive

Buy the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker with 10 Paper Filters on Amazon for $39.99 (originally $49.99)

The Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker is a smart solution if you are on a budget and like your cold-brew mild.

Although the Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker relies on the same cold-brewing principles as the other models we've covered, there are some basic differences. Up to 8 ounces of coffee grounds are added to the filter, which is then screwed into the pitcher, which holds 32 ounces of water. Rather than removing a plug or opening a valve to release the cold brew, you remove the filter and grounds from the water. This leaves you with a pitcher of cold brew concentrate.

Since the Takeya brewer uses half the grounds to produce the same amount of cold brew as the makers we've already mentioned, the resulting concentrate is decidedly weaker. Yet, this may not be a problem since most people dilute their cold brew anyway.

CNET tested the Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker and gave it high marks because it's easy to maintain, well-designed, and it performed well. The reviewer recommended this model for buyers who don't mind a weaker coffee. The Takeya coffee maker is also recommended by Consumer Search, Heavy, and Life Hacker.

The Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker is the preferred cold-brew maker of Insider Picks Guides Editor Les Shu. He likes the price, but it's the convenience that he appreciates: Simply dump the coffee grounds into the filter, add cold water from a Brita, place in the fridge overnight, and you have cold-brew coffee waiting the next morning.

To counter the weakness that many reviewers mentioned, he strongly shakes the bottle for 30 seconds before placing in the fridge — this is where the leak-proof cap comes in handy — which leads a much stronger-tasting concentrate; let it brew for at least 12 hours. The fine mesh of the built-in filter does a good job keeping the grounds from getting into the concentrate. The pitcher also makes it handy for pouring (try making coffee ice cubes).

The filter can be a bit difficult to clean and over time, it will discolor and could take on the taste of a particular coffee. It's not a real issue for most people, and Takeya sells replacement filters.

More than 2,500 Amazon buyers have given the Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker 4 or 5 stars. One customer purchased the Takeya cold brewer to avoid having to constantly go to the local coffee shop for a pricey cold brew and to save money; the customer found this model to be easy to use, and even without using a paper filter, few grounds made their way into the concentrate.

Another buyer really tossed the coffee maker around and found it to be incredibly durable. Buyers recommend using filtered water and a medium or dark roast ground coarse.

Pros: Affordable, fits in your refrigerator door, does not require paper filters, easy to use

Cons: May not satisfy people who like strong coffee

Buy the Takeya Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker on Amazon for $18.99

The Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Iced Coffee Pot has a sleek design that fits into your refrigerator door and produces cold-brewed coffee in just eight hours.

At first glance, the Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Iced Coffee Pot appears to be just like the Takeya brewer. They both use a process where the filter — full of coffee grounds — is removed from the water after steeping. However, the Hario Mizudashi has a filter that requires fewer grounds to fill (about 2.8 ounces.) And, you slowly pour water over the grounds and stir the mixture to start the brewing process. The Hario maker has a glass container versus the plastic of the Takeya.

Hario recommends letting the coffee steep for eight hours, but our research found that this produces a weak concentration. Instead, for a stronger cup of joe, consider brewing the coffee for 12 to 24 hours, like most other cold brew coffee makers.

Oddly Correct recommends the Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Iced Coffee Pot because of how easy it is to use and the strength of the concentrate it produces. However, the reviewer was concerned about the long-term durability of the glass carafe and fine nylon mesh filter.

Coffee Detective likes the Hario Mizudashi for cold-brew lovers who have a small kitchen. The reviewer likes the sleek design but found that the concentrate could have been stronger. And, Stumptown Coffee Roasters appreciates the compact design, but the reviewer found the process of pouring the water into the vessel took 10 minutes.

The Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Iced Coffee Pot has more than 1,700 positive reviews on Amazon. One buyer has used this brewer as the main coffee maker for about a year and has not noticed any signs of wear other than a little discoloration of the filter from coffee. The buyer recommends getting the filter wet, filling it two-thirds of the way with uniformly coarse grounds, and using pure, filtered water.

There are complaints that the directions only came in Japanese. If you come across this issue, you can find English instructions on Hario's website.

Pros: Compact design, durable construction, easy to use, dishwasher safe, doesn't require paper filters

Cons: Produces somewhat weak concentrate

Buy the Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Iced Coffee Pot on Amazon for $21.50 (originally $25)

The Cuisinart Automatic Cold Brew Coffeemaker speeds up the cold-brew process with a spinning chamber that agitates the coffee and the water.

The only real downside to cold brew is that it takes time. If you're impatient and never plan ahead, you may want to try a fast-brewing cold-brew machine like this one from Cuisinart.

We tried it out at home, and though it didn't produce cold-brew that was aromatic and flavorful as our OXO, the coffee it did produce was still delicious and it was ready in just 25 to 45 minutes as opposed to 12 to 24 hours.

The machine is easy to use, though it does require electricity. You simply add ground coffee to the filter basket and fill the water tank with cold or room temperature water. It will take some time to figure out how much water and coffee you want to use, but Cuisinart has very clear guidelines that worked well enough for our tastes.

The machine has three different coffee strengths, each of which corresponds to a different brew time: mild (25 minutes), medium (35 minutes), and bold (45 minutes). Once you've chosen your strength, you press BREW to begin. The coffee filter basket spins to agitate the grounds and the water and speed up the extraction process.

Once it's done brewing, you slide the lever to the release the coffee into the carafe below. The carafe also has a filter top, so you shouldn't get too much sediment in your cup, though you will see some as you reach the end of the carafe. Some people hate this and say it tastes "dirty," but others don't seem to mind.

We thought the Cuisinart Cold Brew Coffeemaker did best on the bold setting, which makes sense because it's the longest period of extraction. Keep in mind that it's not true cold brew because you simply can't beat a good, long extraction time with this type of brewing. Still, for cold-brew in less than an hour, this is the best machine you can buy.

The main concern we had was that the machine has moving parts, so it is more at risk of breaking than the other cold brew makers we recommend, all of which require no electricity. — Malarie Gokey

Pros: Fast brewing process, easy to use, effective, good flavor

Cons: Moving parts risk failure, needs electricity, cold brew purists may not like the speedy extraction time

Buy the Cuisinart Automatic Cold Brew Coffeemaker at Bed Bath & Beyond for $79.99

The best coffee makers you can buy whether you want drip coffee or espresso

A great coffee maker can make or break your brew — and your morning. These are the best coffee makers you can buy, whether you want a drip coffee, French press, espresso, pour-over, or cold brew coffee maker.

We've included top picks for all of these different types of coffee makers. We've tested the majority of our top picks and heavily researched those we have yet to use to bring you the best of all coffee makers.

• Best drip coffee maker: Bonavita BV1900TS Drip Coffee Maker
• Best coffee maker under $40: Mr. Coffee BVMC-SJX33GT Machine
• Best coffee maker under $50: Hamilton Beach 12-Cup Coffee Maker
• Best coffee maker and grinder: Cuisinart Burr Grind & Brew Automatic
• Best pour-over coffee: Melitta Ready Set Joe Single Cup Coffee Brewer
• Best French press: SterlingPro French Press
• Best cold brew machine: OXO Good Grips 4-Cup Cold Brew Coffee Maker
• Best pod coffee machine: Keurig K575 Pod Machine
• Best stovetop espresso maker: Bialetti 6-Cup Stovetop Espresso Maker
• Best espresso machine: Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine

The best coffee and espresso pods you can buy

Coffee and espresso pods are a quick and convenient way to get a delicious cup of joe. While the traditional methods of making coffee and espresso are still the best, machines that brew using capsules are ideal for when you don't have the time to do it the slow way. Here are the best coffee and espresso pods that we think deliver the best-tasting beverage.

• Best Nespresso pods overall: Recaps Stainless Steel Refillable Capsules Reusable Pods
• Best K-Cup pods overall: The Donut Shop's Extra Bold Medium Roast
• Best budget Nespresso pods: Bestpresso
• Best reusable K-Cup pods: IParts Plus More Coffee's reusable K-Cups
• Best single-use Nespresso pods: Nespresso OriginalLine pods
• Best Illy pods: Illy's espresso pods

You can also read our other coffee guides on espresso machines, French presses, stovetop espresso makers, coffee grinders, and milk frothers.