Starting on Wednesday, high winds struck the neighborhood, causing waves to crash over roads.
By Friday morning, lakefront properties were coated in sheets of ice and adorned with icicles.
Strong winds "allowed water to be blown over the homes and freeze to trees and power lines located behind them," broadcast station WGRZ explained.
Source: WGRZ
Local Ed Mis told WGRZ reporter Karys Belger that he had to break into the front of his own house.
"I actually had to go out a secondary door and then chisel my way back into the house by breaking the ice," he said, estimating that ice coating his house was one to three feet thick.
Source: WGRZ
A handful of non-residents have ventured to Hoover Beach to snap photos of the ice formations.
In response, the Town of Hamburg Police Department released a statement reminding sightseers that the houses are private property:
Source: Town of Hamburg Police
According to local reporter John Kucko, boulders shielded a section of the lakefront properties from the storm's brunt forces, whereas others were more exposed to the elements.