The village's 34 homes are built around the perimeter of the island, giving them all waterfront views. The center of the island is occupied by an 18-hole golf course and a country club.
Homes in the ultra-exclusive island community rarely go on the market. Right now, there's only one house for sale: an eight-bedroom, Mediterranean-style mansion for $24 million.
Luxury realtor Nelson Gonzalez gave me a tour of the home, which sits on a 1.2-acre lot.
The home's backyard includes a resort-style pool with a built-in pool lounge.
Several lounge chairs are scattered throughout the pool area.
The 9,709-square-foot waterfront home was built in 1977 and remodeled in 2016.
Alongside the pool is a covered cabana for al fresco dining and entertaining.
The cabana comes with a grill and kitchen area and is outfitted with a TV, lanterns, and ceiling fans.
The house comes with a private boat dock.
From the dock, I spotted the Indian Creek Village Police headquarters across the water, which monitors the only entrance to the island.
After touring the lush grounds, I headed inside the home.
The inside of the home is opulently decorated with high ceilings and chandeliers.
The formal dining room includes intricate wood detailing and a painting of Italy.
A smaller dining area overlooks the backyard.
The chef's kitchen comes with double ovens and a gas range.
Just off the kitchen is a family room that opens up to the backyard and pool area.
Upstairs, the master suite comes with an office and an en-suite bathroom.
The master suite's private balcony overlooks the pool and the dock.
The home has eight bedrooms, 10 full bathrooms, and two half-bathrooms.
One sunny room is set up as a home gym, but it could also be turned into another bedroom.
And a downstairs bedroom is arranged as a children's slumber party room with several bunk beds.