23 unexpected Valentine's Day gifts for him that he'll actually want to keep

With notes of firewood, palo santo, smoke, charcoal, and hay, this candle will fill his space with a natural, woody scent whenever he lights it up. The green glass tumbler will look nice on display too.

Your first thought may be that underwear is a strange gift, but hear us out. MeUndies are so comfortable that they're sure to be his new favorite, and they come in tons of colors and festive, limited-edition prints!

Go for something that's a little different than the classic chocolate hearts. These sweet chocolate treats are shaped like brunch staples, including bacon, eggs, and avocado.

This heated massager is a game-changer for anyone who struggles with back and neck pain on a daily basis. Read a full review here from one of our reporters who swears by it. He'll be thanking you for years to come.

A spicy, tangy sauce unlike anything he's tried before, Truff will light up his taste buds and elevate any meal.

This subscription gives him unlimited access to movies and shows from Disney, Pixar, Marvel, Star Wars, National Geographic, and 20th Century Fox, and costs just $69.99 for a year. Read everything there is to know about Disney+ over here.

And if he needs some binge-spiration, here are all the new movies available to stream.

Packing his toiletries for his next trip will be easy with this vanity case. The exterior material is resistant to water and stains, and the clear window lets him easily identify the case's contents.

Brooklinen has a well-earned reputation as the internet's favorite bedding startup; its sheets are comfortable and luxurious, and its fun new patterns like Graphite Maze (pictured above) instantly upgrade the look of any bedroom.

A cup when he needs it to be and a beer koozie when he wants it, this versatile cooler cup will keep his beverages hot or cold wherever he goes.

If his first love is footwear, he'll appreciate this cool coffee table book all about sneakers. The chapters follow the evolution of sneakers throughout history with photos, quotes, and observations about some of the industry's most monumental moments.

The recently refreshed Kindle Paperwhite is an excellent gift for anyone who loves to read. For under $100, he'll get a Kindle that's now waterproof, as well as thinner, lighter, and with twice the amount of storage for books.

His feet will thank you for keeping them cozy all winter long in these socks made of sustainable hemp fabric.

A mini diffuser will fill his space with some added moisture and his favorite essential oils, so he can breathe easier. This one is great for beginners because it's easy to use and really quiet.

Mott & Bow Dynamic Stretch jeans are beloved by all of the men on the Insider Picks team for their comfort, their clean and modern look, and their durability.

A fresh scent and bright colors make floral bouquets a wonderful gift that they'll love to keep on display. There's a reason flowers are a classic.

Whether it's their favorite city or the exact location where you met, you can be sure they'll appreciate the sentimentality of this personalized poster, which turns a map of any location you choose into a unique piece of art.

This shave kit from Harry's has all of the essentials they need for a clean shave — a razor, shave cream, and travel blade cover — in TSA-friendly sizes. Plus, it's packed in a sturdy waterproof case that they can use again and again.

This hat is a fan favorite — it has over 7,000 5-star reviews on Amazon. It's made of a soft, yet durable material, has a classic fit, and comes in lots of colors, so it's no wonder people love it so much.

For the fitness junkie, you can bring the gym home with this TRX trainer. He'll appreciate the thoughtful, practical gift.

If his veins run dark roast, we recommend a subscription to the Atlas Coffee Club, which curates a global selection of single-origin coffee that gets freshly roasted and shipped to his house from $9 per bag.

This set of over 500 magnets can be mashed, rolled, and molded into different shapes. It's a productivity toy that he'll love to play with. You'll find a set on nearly every one of our desks at Insider Picks.

If flowers aren't really their thing, go for something that's more their taste — like this salami bouquet. It's an arrangement they can really enjoy.