1. (TIE) Casa Velas Luxury Boutique-Puerto Vallarta, Mexico

Hotels.com average guest rating: 4.7/5

Price: From $316/night

This luxury hotel is tied in first place with the highest user rating. It's a lot smaller than some of the other resorts, with only 80 bedrooms, two restaurants, and one outdoor pool, but this makes it a better choice for those who want more peace. Guests can spend extra and buy a golf and spa package to use the hotel's spa facilities and neighboring golf course.