We tried McDonald's, Wendy's, and Burger King's signature burgers - and the winner is unmistakable
Here is the storied and gloried lineup: the Whopper from Burger King, the Dave's Single from Wendy's, and the Big Mac from McDonald's.
Unwrapping them is like driving off the lot — once it's done, there's no going back. The Whopper and the Big Mac have held up well, but the Dave's Single looks like a flat tire.
Let's start with the Whopper. There is simply no Burger King without the Whopper. It's as entwined with the chain as the croissant is to France. It is indeed the "Home of the Whopper".
The Whopper is a delightfully simple item: a flame-grilled quarter-pound beef patty topped with lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, onion slices, mayonnaise, and ketchup, all tucked under a sesame seed bun. Technically the Whopper doesn't have cheese, but since every cashier asks, "With cheese?", and every customer should say yes because no one should say no to cheese, I'm including a slice of American cheese as part of the classic burger.
In reviews past, Burger King has typically scored pretty low on the quality metric. The sandwiches are rather consistently slapdash, soggy, and over-sauced. But this Whopper has bucked the trend entirely. The extremely wide, flat sandwich has a very good balance of burger-to-condiment ratio, and the bun envelopes it all without becoming waterlogged.
The pickles are surprisingly tart, and add a much more satisfying crunch than the onions. The big, beautiful, sesame seed dotted mesa of a bun is incredibly wide, translating into a lot of bread. It almost overwhelms the thin patty at times. The meat itself is so-so, but the cheese adds a bit of richness to each bite. Burger King is known for its rather brash stunt items as of late, but the Whopper is a sedate and steadfast anchor on the menu.
The Big Mac: snugly between blue jeans and Springsteen's "Born in the USA" on the scale of international symbols for America. How many burgers can say they have an economic index named after them? This double-decker burger is more iconic than London's double-decker buses, and I would assume a more satisfying meal experience.
Yeah, it's true — the Big Mac Index is a thing.
Two thin patties, shredded lettuce, onions, American cheese, pickles, the instantly recognizable three-piece bun, and of course, the sacred secret sauce, all come together to create this famous burger.
Of course, by now we all know the secret sauce is far from secret. In 2012, McDonald's executive chef Dan Coudreaut let slip the magic behind the legendary concoction in a PR video.
There's something about the Big Mac that just... clicks. Sure, the bun is suspiciously sweet — I'm sure a large amount of sugar is to blame — and the patties are thin. Yet the sandwich is balanced. Every bite gives the right amount of bun, beef, condiments, and toppings. The tart pickles play with the velvety sauce perfectly, and the sandwich has a satisfying heft while avoiding being overwhelming.
Now to Wendy's burger, the Dave's Single. Wendy's flagship burger line has been reworked several times throughout the chain's 46 year history; most recently in 2011. The enduring Wendy's Single (and Double, etc.) was revamped and christened the Dave's Hot N' Juicy, shortened to simply Dave's Single in 2016. We decided to go for the Single variation for this test for simplicity's sake, as the Whopper is comparable as a single-patty burger.
The Single consists of Wendy's iconic quarter-pound square patty sandwiched between two slices of American cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, pickles, red onions, ketchup, and mayonnaise, all cradled within the recently revamped premium bun.
But something is afoot here. In the ghosts of burger reviews past, there have been many a sloppy, soggy, saucy burger— almost consistently from Burger King. But here, Wendy's is the culprit. This burger is smushed, swampy, and slathered, and I'm shocked. It was ordered during the lunch time rush, and a similar burger from the same order came out beautifully, so I'll give the benefit of the doubt here. But it's troubling, nonetheless.
It's soggy. So, so soggy. But let's look at the positives. The square beef patty is thick and juicy, and the red onion slices add a lot more bite and zest than the white onions from the competition. But in bites where there were no crunchy onion, the sandwich quickly devolved into a bland, mayo-logged mess.
It almost seems as though Burger King and Wendy's have gone through a Freaky Friday-style transformation here. As to which is Jamie Lee Curtis as Lindsay Lohan and which is Lindsay Lohan as Jamie Lee Curtis, I cannot say.
And so, the winner of the signature burger showdown has to be the imitable Big Mac. The Whopper comes in at a solid second place, as a rather dignified yet somewhat humdrum flagship. And in a shocking third comes Wendy's Dave's Single. Usually Wendy's competes with the best of burgers, but the haphazard prep dragged the tasting experience down fast.
Just look at it: The Big Mac is the shining standard of signature burgers. An instantly recognizable profile, a "secret" sauce, and a name synonymous with American cuisine — it has it all. This is a sandwich that holds the heart and soul of fast-food within its three-piece bun.
Get your weekly dose of essential news delivered right to you, plus explore a world of insights with our diverse newsletter subscription options.
- Weekly newsletter
- Uncover the latest in Tech, Finance, Business, and more
- Handpicked web stories, in-depth articles, and expert analyses
Advertisement