I tried on basic black sweaters from Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap. My top choice reminded me that you get what you pay for.

Chloe CaldwellOct 18, 2024, 20:41 IST

I tried on similar black sweaters at Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap.Chloe Caldwell<ul class="summary-list"><li>I tried on similar sweaters at <a target="_blank" class href="https://www.businessinsider.com/review-trying-on-jeans-old-navy-banana-republic-gap-2024-9">Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap</a>.</li><li>I liked the fit of the Old Navy sweater but was disappointed in the fabric quality.</li></ul>It's officially the season of overpriced <a target="_blank" class href="https://www.businessinsider.com/starbucks-pumpkin-spice-latte-recipe-2023-9">pumpkin-spice lattes</a>, spooky movies, and homemade chili, which means it's time to restock my fall-fashion staples.I typically do my seasonal shopping at thrift stores, but I've been on the lookout for a neutral sweater that will actually last more than a few wears and washes.That's why I turned to three Gap Inc.-owned retailers — Banana Republic, <a target="_blank" class href="https://www.businessinsider.com/old-navy-rise-and-fall-photos-history-2020-1">Old Navy</a>, and Gap — to find a simple but versatile black sweater. I compared similar styles based on comfort, texture, design, fit, and overall value.Here's how the <a target="_blank" class href="https://www.businessinsider.com/what-aeropostale-is-like-in-2024-according-to-millennial">shopping experience</a> went.

I began my search at Banana Republic and was impressed by the luxe layout of the store.

The Banana Republic location I visited offered an elevated-boutique experience.Chloe Caldwell

I decided to try on a black sweater made of 100% cashmere.

I tried on a $150 cashmere sweater at Banana Republic.Chloe Caldwell

Even though the sweater cost $150, I thought it was worth the price.

This sweater reminded me of a cozy blanket.Chloe Caldwell

Next, I visited Old Navy.

Old Navy has over 1,200 locations worldwide.Chloe Caldwell

Old Navy wasn't as organized as Banana Republic, but I was able to find what I was looking for.

I found a black V-neck sweater to try on.Chloe Caldwell

I liked the fit of the Old Navy sweater but was disappointed in the fabric quality.

The Old Navy sweater fit me nicely, but the fabric felt a bit rough.Chloe Caldwell

I ended my shopping trip at Gap, which sells foundational pieces and everyday essentials.

Gap has 700 locations in North America and Asia.Chloe Caldwell

I love Gap's boutique-style layout.

I'm always impressed by the shopping experience at Gap.Chloe Caldwell

The material was soft and comfortable, but I didn’t love the shape or fit of the Gap sweater.

The Gap version was my least favorite of all three sweaters I tried on.Chloe Caldwell

After trying on sweaters at all three stores, I would be most likely to invest in the Banana Republic option.

I tried on similar black sweaters at Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap.Chloe Caldwell

8 details you missed at the first Victoria's Secret Fashion Show in 6 years

Cookies on the Business Insider India website