Saudi Arabia is starting a reckless oil war with Russia - but the US is also a target

• Russia appears to be the target of the oil war launched by Saudi Arabia this week, but the US, as a net exporter and the world's largest oil producer, should also be considered a target.
• This attack comes from a country that the US has shown deference to, and while Riyadh doesn't have to be viewed as an enemy, they shouldn't be seen as an ally, argues Enea Gjoza.
• Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.

In a reckless move characteristic of his leadership, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad Bin Salman, known as MBS, spurred an oil crisis this week that cratered financial markets and could devastate American oil producers.

After Saudi Arabia indicated it will massively ramp up oil production, oil prices experienced their biggest one day drop in three decades. The Dow Jones Industrial Average also fell by 2,000 points, its biggest point drop ever.

The markets will recover from the initial shock, but the vibrant US oil industry might be irreparably harmed by an ostensible ally the US has gone to great lengths to appease.

The crisis was preceded by a joint Saudi-Russian initiative to shore up oil prices in the wake of the coronavirus. With China and other countries on lockdown, demand for oil fell sharply, even as producers worldwide continued to pump the same amount.

To prevent a price collapse, OPEC - led by Saudi Arabia - and Russia attempted to negotiate production cuts of nearly 1 million barrels per day (bpd). Those talks fell apart this weekend after Russia refused a deal that would have seen it bear half of that reduction.

Instead of settling for the status quo and injecting stability into a system already grappling with worldwide economic and social upheaval, MBS chose to burn the house down.

Saudi Arabia announced a massive increase in crude oil production from 9.7 million bpd to 12.3 million, a record amount that would likely involve tapping into its stores. It also offered substantial discounts to buyers in Europe, Asia, and the US - a move intended to capture market share from competitors.

For its part, Russia doubled down and threatened to increase its own production, setting up a potentially lengthy slump in the oil markets.

The Saudi move appears designed to punish Russia, but unspoken is the obvious target - the world's largest oil producer, the US.

In the past six years, the shale oil revolution transformed the US from the world's biggest oil importer to a net exporter. In the process, US producers captured market share from Saudi Arabia and Russia, the other oil superpowers.

Unlike those nations, where large, state-linked enterprises dominate the market, the US market is full of smaller firms that are burdened with debt and facing shrinking margins. Without government backing, they depend on fair market prices for survival.

Saudi Arabia already tried - and failed - to destroy shale oil once. In 2014 and 2015, the Kingdom engineered a crash in oil prices that caused widespread bankruptcies among US shale oil firms and destroyed thousands of good jobs, although the industry survived. MBS appears to be giving it another go, this time in the middle of a global crisis that is already threatening to depress worldwide energy demand for some time.

The US oil industry will no doubt survive, but many jobs could be lost in one of the few fields where Americans without a college degree can earn a six-figure income. Already, the White House is contemplating a rescue of the industry.

The Saudi-orchestrated crash is particularly galling coming from a nation to which the US has shown great deference. The US supported the Saudi war in Yemen with ammunition, refueling, and intelligence, even though that conflict is disconnected from US interests and Saudi Arabia's humanitarian violations have tarnished America's reputation.

The US also sold the Saudis weapons that ended up in the hands of Al-Qaeda-linked militias and overlooked the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, a Saudi dissident and US resident. Only five months ago, US troops, aircraft, and Patriot batteries were deployed to the Middle East to safeguard the Kingdom from Iran.

The British statesman Lord Palmerston famously opined that nations don't have permanent allies, only interests, and the Saudis have certainly behaved that way, pursuing their interests to the exclusion of friends and enemies alike.

It is time for the US to do the same. Saudi Arabia is neither an ally nor an adversary, and the US-Saudi relationship is ripe for re-evaluation: The US should work with the Saudis where our interests align and allow them to go their own way where they diverge.

The latest gambit by MBS could well be a miscalculation, with Russia well positioned to outlast the Saudis, even as the Saudi state faces large fiscal obligations and domestic elites challenge the Crown Prince's authority. Next time the Saudis ask the US to bail them out of a crisis of their own making, the US should show them the door.

Enea Gjoza is a Senior Fellow at Defense Priorities.