Malcolm Gladwell has a huge problem with a government handout given to America's Ivy League
Each year, with the help of in-house private equity managers, those universities can grow their endowments - sometimes by huge margins.
But they also have an extra boost that normal hedge funds and private equity funds do not: They are not taxed on their earnings because they're nonprofit institutions. That benefit should be reevaluated, Jordan Weissmann argues in Slate on Monday.
Those tax exemptions provided to private colleges can essentially be thought of as American taxpayers subsidizing private endowment funds. At a simplified level, any exemption in one area increases taxes in another area, ultimately falling on the back of the American taxpayer.
What's more, tax breaks for private universities amount to more money than the federal funding public universities receive, according to Weissmann. He argues that the gap between federal funding for public universities and the tax breaks private universities enjoy on their endowment income necessitates a tax on private endowments.
Slate cites a report by two researchers who compared the amount of money private universities save on tax breaks on their endowments, to government funding provided to public universities.
Mark Schneider, a former Department of Education official who now works at the American Institutes for Research, and Jorge Klor de Alva, a former president of the University of Phoenix who is now president of Nexus Research and Policy Center, found that gap is enormous.
For example, Princeton received $105,000 in tax breaks per student, while Rutgers University, a public university, received just $12,300 per student in public funding. Both schools are located in New Jersey.
In Massachusetts, Harvard received $48,000 in tax breaks per student, while the University of Massachusetts-Amherst received $9,900 in public funding.
The large discrepancy is leading some higher education pundits to criticize the ability of private college endowments to amass huge endowments without being taxed on income.
Famed author Malcolm Gladwell has recently been highly critical of certain financial decisions at the Ivy League, and commented on the report in a series of pointed tweets.