Magic Leap
- Magic Leap showed off some video filmed through its yet-to-launch smart glasses on Thursday.
- Reactions online were mixed - many observers said they were underwhelmed.
- Magic Leap CEO Rony Abovitz shot back in a series of Thursday morning tweets.
Magic Leap CEO Rony Abovitz said that video can't properly capture his startup's much-hyped technology after a livestreamed demo drew mixed reviews.
Magic Leap is building a pair of smartglasses that merge computer graphics and games into the real world, and Wednesday's livestream showed off some of the first public footage captured through the device.
"For the creator/dev community: we use video to teach a feature or capability. Any video or 2d medium (photos) is completely inadequate to actually deliver the experience of a digital lightfield on ML1," he tweeted on Thursday.
He was likely referencing the mixed response to Thursday's livestream from journalists and some competitors in the augmented reality field. Thursday's livestream was geared for developers, who will need to build games and other content for the system before it's launched to the public, but the demos were eagerly watched by enthusiasts as well.
The full session is available on YouTube, but here's one of the demos, featuring a new rock character:
The reaction was mostly critical:
There were some defenders, though:
This is the context in which Abovitz issued a long tweetstorm in which he argued that the demo may be underwhelming because it's hard to experience Magic Leap without actually putting the headset on.
"You could never experience TV on the radio (but you could try and explain the theory of TV to those interested)" Abovitz tweeted. "Most people just got it once they first saw TV."
Asa Mathat for Vox Media
On Wednesday, Magic Leap announced an investment from AT&T and a partnership with the telecom giant, along with an update about the availability of its smart glasses, committing to ship its hardware to some developers this summer. A price tag and ship date have yet to be announced.
The startup has raised $2.3 billion in funding from investors, including Google, Alibaba, Singapore's Temasek Holdings, and Saudi Arabia's sovereign investment arm, valuing the company at over $6 billion. Business Insider parent company Axel Springer is an investor, too.
Here's the full tweetstorm:
Here's that tweetstorm in paragraph form, lightly edited:
"For the creator/dev community: we use video to teach a feature or capability. Any video or 2d medium (photos) is completely inadequate to actually deliver the experience of a digital lightfield on ML1. We spend our time and R and D tuning our Digital Lightfield Signal to the eye-brain system, not electronic camera sensors. We spend our time and R and D tuning our Digital Lightfield Signal to the eye-brain system, not electronic camera sensors.
Video capture can not differentiate between phone AR, VR, MR - the relevant differentiating information is lost. That said, a direct Digital Lightfield signal that allows your eye-brain system to do its thing, that is where all the magic happens. Reality has an amazing sense of presence and space - that is the result of incredibly complex interactions with the world's analog lightfield signal and your brain.Our work at Magic Leap has been to approximate that experience with a digital signal designed to fit into, and mimic, that interaction we all have daily.
An actual ML1 experience fundamentally needs you, does not function well without you, and was designed to unveil its technical magic with you and to you. Anyone who has already had an ML experience on a shipping grade unit already knows this. And hopefully anyone curious or interested will have the opportunity soon to try for themselves.
You could never experience TV on the radio (but you could try and explain the theory of TV to those interested). Most people just got it once they first saw TV. Same with Magic Leap."
Watch the entire Magic Leap demo for yourself below:
Know anything about Magic Leap? Email the author at kleswing@businessinsider.com
Magic Leap in 2015: Our mixed reality headset lets you fight digital space aliens and robots using real-world 3D printed weapons!
Magic Leap in 2016: LOOK. ALL THESE KIDS ARE SEEING A WHALE IN A GYM.
Magic Leap today (2018): This little dude can throw rocks at you. pic.twitter.com/fSOv7c6GwF
- David Chen (@davechensky) July 12, 2018
I'm glad that the annoying hype is coming to an end for Magic Leap. Billions of dollars can't change the laws of physics for wave guide optics.
- Jeri Ellsworth (@jeriellsworth) July 12, 2018
Magic Leap's first demo is anything but impressive.https://t.co/vfmzt9kGMJ pic.twitter.com/Ef5p4LE3PV
- ExtremeTech (@ExtremeTech) July 12, 2018
I continue to be amused by people who have never seen Magic Leap's product asserting that it sucks and that people who have seen it must all be wrong.
- Benedict Evans (@BenedictEvans) July 12, 2018
For the creator/dev community: we use video to teach a feature or capability. Any video or 2d medium (photos) is completely inadequate to actually deliver the experience of a digital lightfield on ML1.
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
We spend our time and R and D tuning our Digital Lightfield Signal to the eye-brain system, not electronic camera sensors.
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
During ML1 development we have given over 10,000 actual live demos. And we will be creating as many opportunities as possible post launch for hands-on experience as well.
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
Video capture can not differentiate between phone AR, VR, MR - the relevant differentiating information is lost
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
That said, a direct Digital Lightfield signal that allows your eye-brain system to do its thing, that is where all the magic happens ๐
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
Reality has an amazing sense of presence and space - that is the result of incredibly complex interactions with the world's analog lightfield signal and your brain
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
Our work @magicleap has been to approximate that experience with a digital signal designed to fit into, and mimic, that interaction we all have daily.
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
An actual ML1 experience fundamentally needs you, does not function well without you, and was designed to unveil its technical magic with you and to you.
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
Anyone who has already had an ML experience on a shipping grade unit already knows this. And hopefully anyone curious or interested will have the opportunity soon to try for themselves ๐
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
You could never experience TV on the radio (but you could try and explain the theory of TV to those interested). Most people just got it once they first saw TV. Same with @magicleap
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018
We @magicleap believe it important to still communicate lessons (basic and advanced) and features and cool new tools to creators through video - that can be useful now and even more so post ship.
- Rony Abovitz (@rabovitz) July 12, 2018