Wall Street's consensus isn't always reliable, according to new research.Getty Images
- Investors gravitate toward the same stocks to their detriment, a new report indicates.
- Companies that Wall Street analysts disagree about tend to outperform over time.
There's an old saying that remains relevant to investors: If we all think alike, no one is thinking.
Groupthink is prevalent everywhere, including on Wall Street. With the exception of a few outspoken contrarians, investors tend to ride the stock market's momentum instead of going against the grain since missing a massive rally can be costly — especially for fund managers.
However, picking the same stocks as everyone else can hinder outperformance.
Stocks that equity analysts agree either have a bright or dismal future have historically lagged behind those that the Street is split on, according to a mid-March report from UBS.
The firm found that companies with a higher so-called ratings dispersion from analysts have beaten those with low dispersions by 1.6% a year since the end of 2010. High-dispersion stocks have outperformed their low-dispersion peers 74% of the time in that span, UBS noted.
For reference, high-ratings-dispersion stocks' returns are better than high growth over low growth and high momentum over low momentum. Even still, this strategy is usually overlooked.
Within this high-dispersion strategy, companies tied to technology or adjacent sectors tend to perform best, according to UBS. Another reason to consider this method is that it has a low correlation to other stocks, which is a risk-management plus.
30 stocks that Wall Street is split onSince analyst alignment can be a bad omen for companies, it follows that investors should look for firms that can spark debates among those who follow them.
Below are 30 stocks with the highest dispersion in ratings from analysts, sorted alphabetically by sector and within their sector, if applicable. Along with each name is its ticker, market capitalization, and sector. Note that UBS doesn't necessarily recommend these companies.
1. Electronic Arts
Markets Insider
Ticker: EA
Market cap: $36.6B
Sector: Communication Services
2. Paramount Global
Markets Insider
Ticker: PARA
Market cap: $8.1B
Sector: Communication Services
3. Verizon Communications
Markets Insider
Ticker: VZ
Market cap: $169.4B
Sector: Communication Services
4. Warner Bros. Discovery
Markets Insider
Ticker: WBD
Market cap: $21.7B
Sector: Communication Services
5. CarMax
Markets Insider
Ticker: KMX
Market cap: $13.1B
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
6. Carnival
Markets Insider
Ticker: CCL
Market cap: $21B
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
7. Ford Motor
Markets Insider
Ticker: F
Market cap: $49.4B
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
8. Lululemon Athletica
Markets Insider
Ticker: LULU
Market cap: $56.8B
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
9. Pool
Markets Insider
Ticker: POOL
Market cap: $15.5B
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
10. Tesla
Markets Insider
Ticker: TSLA
Market cap: $538.8B
Sector: Consumer Discretionary
11. APA Corp.
Markets Insider
Ticker: APA
Market cap: $9.8B
Sector: Energy
12. EQT Corp.
Markets Insider
Ticker: EQT
Market cap: $15.1B
Sector: Energy
13. American Express
Markets Insider
Ticker: AXP
Market cap: $161.4B
Sector: Financials
14. Ameriprise Financial
Markets Insider
Ticker: AMP
Market cap: $41.6B
Sector: Financials
15. CME Group
Markets Insider
Ticker: CME
Market cap: $78.6B
Sector: Financials
16. Comerica
Markets Insider
Ticker: CMA
Market cap: $6.9B
Sector: Financials
17. Northern Trust
Markets Insider
Ticker: NTRS
Market cap: $16.8B
Sector: Financials
18. PNC Financial Services
Markets Insider
Ticker: PNC
Market cap: $60.9B
Sector: Financials
19. Align Technology
Markets Insider
Ticker: ALGN
Market cap: $24B
Sector: Healthcare
20. Amgen
Markets Insider
Ticker: AMGN
Market cap: $148.3B
Sector: Healthcare
21. Edwards Lifesciences
Markets Insider
Ticker: EW
Market cap: $55.5B
Sector: Healthcare
22. Illumina
Markets Insider
Ticker: ILMN
Market cap: $21.1B
Sector: Healthcare
23. Steris
Markets Insider
Ticker: STE
Market cap: $23B
Sector: Healthcare
24. Vertex Pharmaceuticals
Markets Insider
Ticker: VRTX
Market cap: $107B
Sector: Healthcare
25. Carrier Global
Markets Insider
Ticker: CARR
Market cap: $52.6B
Sector: Industrials
26. Caterpillar
Markets Insider
Ticker: CAT
Market cap: $170.9B
Sector: Industrials
27. Generac
Markets Insider
Ticker: GNRC
Market cap: $7B
Sector: Industrials
28. Old Dominion Freight Line
Markets Insider
Ticker: ODFL
Market cap: $47.8B
Sector: Industrials
29. Rockwell Automation
Markets Insider
Ticker: ROK
Market cap: $32.9B
Sector: Industrials
30. United Rentals
Markets Insider
Ticker: URI
Market cap: $45.5B
Sector: Industrials