scorecard
  1. Home
  2. insider picks
  3. news
  4. I made Martha Stewart's slow cooker mac and cheese and it was the creamiest, most flavorful kind I've ever had

I made Martha Stewart's slow cooker mac and cheese and it was the creamiest, most flavorful kind I've ever had

Erin McDowell   

I made Martha Stewart's slow cooker mac and cheese and it was the creamiest, most flavorful kind I've ever had
Martha Stewart's three-cheese macaroni and cheese was one of the best meals I've ever made in a slow cooker.Erin McDowell/Insider/Manny Carabel/Getty Images

I've made a multitude of slow cooker dishes in the past but never one from a celebrity chef's cookbook. I decided to try some by Martha Stewart.

I
Martha Stewart holding her "Slow Cooker" cookbook.      Manny Carabel/Getty Images

After trying my hand at three recipes from "Martha Stewart's Slow Cooker," I was blown away by her recipe for a three-cheese macaroni and cheese. I thought the dish was delicious and different from any other mac and cheese I've had before.

For her three-cheese macaroni and cheese, you need - you guessed it - three kinds of cheese, milk, and two cans of evaporated milk to make it extra creamy.

For her three-cheese macaroni and cheese, you need - you guessed it - three kinds of cheese, milk, and two cans of evaporated milk to make it extra creamy.
Macaroni and cheese ingredients.      Erin McDowell/Insider

The recipe also includes sautéed onions, Dijon mustard, and seasoning. From the recipe list, I had a suspicion this was going to be a decadent dish.

You can find the full recipe in "Martha Stewart's Slow Cooker."

I use a Rival Crock-Pot that comes with four heat settings and a warm setting.

I use a Rival Crock-Pot that comes with four heat settings and a warm setting.
My Rival Crock-Pot.      Erin McDowell/Insider

The slow cooker I use allows you to cook on high for four or six hours, or on low for eight or 10 hours. After the slow cooker timer is finished, it will automatically move to the warm setting.

For most dishes I cook in the slow cooker, I manually move the setting to warm because they usually don't need the full cooking time.

I started by dicing half of a white onion. I've never used onion in mac and cheese before but found it added a ton of flavor to the dish.

I started by dicing half of a white onion. I
Chopped white onion.      Erin McDowell/Insider

You can also add more or less depending on how strong you want the onion flavor to be.

I sautéed the onion in a nonstick pan until it softened.

I sautéed the onion in a nonstick pan until it softened.
White onion sauteed in a pan.      Erin McDowell/Insider

The recipe recommended softening the onion in a tablespoon of butter, rather than oil.

After I shredded the cheese by hand, I added the ingredients to the slow cooker along with the onions.

After I shredded the cheese by hand, I added the ingredients to the slow cooker along with the onions.
Cheese and onions in the slow cooker.      Erin McDowell/Insider

It took quite a bit of work to grate the cheese by hand, and it got a tad messy on the counter. You can also buy your cheese pre-shredded to save yourself a little extra time. However, the cookbook does recommend getting the highest quality cheese you have access to.

Even though it took a little extra effort to hand-grate the cheese, I felt it added to the final result — the different types of cheese combined perfectly together.

The recipe calls for three cups of white sharp cheddar cheese and one cup of Gruyere in the macaroni and cheese mixture. The third and final cheese, Parmigiano Reggiano, is later added to the breadcrumb mixture.

One of the best parts about this recipe is that you don't have to sit around waiting for the macaroni to boil.

One of the best parts about this recipe is that you don
Macaroni and cheese ingredients in the slow cooker.      Erin McDowell/Insider

Instead, you simply throw it in with the other ingredients and it cooks itself.

I added in the uncooked macaroni noodles after adding in both kinds of milk, a teaspoon of Dijon mustard, salt, and pepper on top of the onions.

While the macaroni and cheese was cooking in the Crock-Pot, I prepared the homemade breadcrumbs.

While the macaroni and cheese was cooking in the Crock-Pot, I prepared the homemade breadcrumbs.
Homemade breadcrumbs toasting in a stainless steel pan.      Erin McDowell/Insider

I made the breadcrumbs by pulsing two slices of bread in a food processor. I then toasted them on the stove for a few minutes until they were golden brown and slightly crispy.

I recommend using higher-quality peasant bread or sourdough.

I mixed the toasted breadcrumbs with the Parmesan cheese in a small bowl.

I mixed the toasted breadcrumbs with the Parmesan cheese in a small bowl.
The breadcrumbs mixed with Parmesan.      Erin McDowell/Insider

The recipe calls for just a quarter-cup of cheese. I used the freshly grated kind from my local grocery store.

The macaroni and cheese only took an hour and a half on high to finish cooking - it was much quicker than other slow cooker recipes I've tried.

The macaroni and cheese only took an hour and a half on high to finish cooking - it was much quicker than other slow cooker recipes I
Cooked mac and cheese in the slow cooker.      Erin McDowell/Insider

One of my pet peeves about slow cooking is the planning and preparation it takes to do, largely due to how you have to start prepping your dinner around midday if you want it to be done in time.

Being able to start cooking and have dinner done in an hour and a half, without having to wait patiently by the stove, made this dish really convenient. Other slow cooker recipes I've tried have taken up to six hours, so I thought this was a serious asset.

This was by far one of the easiest recipes I've ever made in a slow cooker, and it wasn't too expensive either.

This was by far one of the easiest recipes I
Cooked mac and cheese in the slow cooker topped with breadcrumbs.      Erin McDowell/Insider

I topped the macaroni and cheese with breadcrumbs and let it continue cooking, covered, for another 15 minutes.

The ingredients for the macaroni and cheese, which could have easily fed up to eight people, came to $33.38 at my local grocery store. That's just over $4 per serving.

The macaroni and cheese was rich and creamy, and the breadcrumbs added a crispy texture.

The macaroni and cheese was rich and creamy, and the breadcrumbs added a crispy texture.
A spoonful of the finished mac and cheese.      Erin McDowell/Insider

The cheese added a ton of flavor, especially the smoked Gruyere, while the onions made the dish even more delicious. This was by far the most flavorful macaroni and cheese I've ever had, and I thought it was very easy to make.

My only complaint was that the bottom layer of macaroni and cheese could have been a tad creamier — it was a little watery compared to the top layers. However, it probably would have cooked through more evenly with a little longer in the slow cooker.

In fact, after leaving it on the warm setting for another hour or so while I ate, it got even better. This would be a great macaroni and cheese for a party since you can serve it and keep it warm throughout the day.

READ MORE ARTICLES ON

Advertisement