scorecardHere are the shows and actors that should (but probably won't) get Emmy nominations this year
  1. Home
  2. entertainment
  3. news
  4. Here are the shows and actors that should (but probably won't) get Emmy nominations this year

Here are the shows and actors that should (but probably won't) get Emmy nominations this year

Caralynn Lippo,Debanjali Bose,Kim Renfro,Kirsten Acuna,Joi-Marie McKenzie   

Here are the shows and actors that should (but probably won't) get Emmy nominations this year
Perhaps the Emmys will show a little love to genre TV this year.Hulu, Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Studios
  • The Emmy Awards don't always recognize the most deserving shows and actors.
  • Certain genres get ignored and critically-acclaimed performances can slip under the radar.
  • Insider hopes these long-shots get some love when Emmy nominations are announced Tuesday.

Emmy nominations are almost here, and you know what that means: Disappointment is on the horizon!

Emmy nominations are almost here, and you know what that means: Disappointment is  on the horizon!
Viola Davis holding her Emmy award at the 67th Primetime Emmy Awards in 2015.      Mike Blake/Reuters

This year, the 73rd Primetime Emmy Awards aim to recognize the best in TV programming among shows and limited series that aired from June 1, 2020 to May 31, 2021. But we don't have a lot of hope that everything we loved this past year will make it onto the ballots.

It's a common gripe that awards shows, in general, can be extremely predictable and kinda boring. With TV especially, the Academy has a tendency to fall into a pattern of nominating (and awarding) the same very small, select group of actors and series throughout a show's entire run.

The Emmys also have a tendency to ignore genre shows — with the notable exception of "Game of Thrones" — in favor of mystery-thrillers, historical fiction, and prestige cable and streaming dramas. (We're predicting lots of 2021 Emmys love for "Mare of Easttown," "The Crown," "The Queen's Gambit," and "The Handmaid's Tale," in case you hadn't guessed.)

So, it's inevitable that there'll be oversights when the nominations are announced on Tuesday morning.

While there'll be plenty of griping about perceived snubs to do then, here are the shows and actors Insider's entertainment team is hoping against hope will get a nod (even though we've been doing this long enough to be pretty sure most of them won't).

Antony Starr deserves an Emmy nomination for playing one of the most terrifying villains on television in "The Boys."

Antony Starr deserves an Emmy nomination for playing one of the most terrifying villains on television in "The Boys."
Amazon Studios

Starr's Homelander gets even more menacing on season two of "The Boys," and his performance has been captivating since the series first premiered in 2019.

Unfortunately, the Television Academy doesn't typically know what to do with genre shows, let alone off-beat, subversive genre shows like this one.

—Caralynn Lippo, Entertainment Editor

"Pen15" season 2 could get a nod for best comedy series, but Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle deserve individual nominations for their acting performances too.

"Pen15" season 2 could get a nod for best comedy series, but Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle deserve individual nominations for their acting performances too.
People are appreciating "Pen15" but the two leads deserve more love for their performances.      Lara Solanki/Hulu

The first season of Hulu's "Pen15" (a comedy series about the early aughts middle school experiences of Maya and Anna) was rightfully nominated for best comedy series, but both Erskine and Konkle were overlooked for acting awards.

Hopefully this time around they are both properly lauded for the incredible nuance and hilarity they bring to a show where the now 30-something women play their own 13-year-old selves among a cast of real middle-schoolers.

—Kim Renfro, Entertainment Correspondent

Amazon original "The Wilds" is low-key one of the best dramas of the year.

Amazon original "The Wilds" is low-key one of the best dramas of the year.
"The Wilds" had one of the year's most gripping finales so far.      Amazon Studios

"The Wilds" has a premise that sounds a little bit like an aged-down "Lost" knock-off: a group of teenage girls are left stranded on a deserted island after a plane crash. But its twists, turns, and strong ensemble performances made it one of the most engaging, must-watch dramas of the year.

It was also tightly crafted, holding our interest throughout the entirety of the first season right up to that shocking finale and managing to avoid the wheel-spinning "filler" episodes that shows of this genre often turn to in an effort to draw out the mystery.

—Debanjali Bose, Associate Editor

Olivia Holt delivers one of the most powerful dramatic performances of the year in "Cruel Summer."

Olivia Holt delivers one of the most powerful dramatic performances of the year in "Cruel Summer."
Olivia Holt surprised us in what could have been a very flat role.      Freeform/Bill Matlock

Playing a survivor of grooming, sexual assault, and kidnapping, Holt delivers a flawless and authentic portrayal of someone living through PTSD in her role as Kate Wallis on the surprise Freeform hit "Cruel Summer."

There's no doubt in our minds that Holt's nomination would be a gimme if the show aired on any network other than Freeform.

—Debanjali Bose, Associate Editor, and Caralynn Lippo, Entertainment Editor

Starz's "Run the World" is definitely Emmy worthy - and we hope the Academy has already taken notice.

Starz
It's so much more than the next "Sex and the City."      Starz

"Run the World" centers on four best friends, living in Harlem, as they navigate love, career, and friendships. If it sounds familiar, it's because it sorta kinda is: The woman behind "Living Single," which also centered four besties living in Brooklyn, Yvette Lee Bowser, is also the show's executive producer.

However, creator and executive producer Leigh Davenport brings a special freshness to the series, perfectly capturing the essence of what it means to live in a concrete jungle while trying to find beauty everywhere — even in the corner bodega, Central Park, or a blue-lit club while trying to crash VIP.

—Joi-Marie McKenzie, Deputy Editor

The extremely charming "Mighty Ducks: Game Changers" far exceeds our expectations.

The extremely charming "Mighty Ducks: Game Changers" far exceeds our expectations.
Between this and "Cobra Kai," unexpected TV continuations of beloved '80s and '90s film franchises are really having a moment.      Disney/Liane Hentscher

It's like "Ted Lasso" for the younger set.

We didn't have very high hopes for this TV continuation of the beloved 1990s film series (they can't all be "Cobra Kai," after all). But a clever premise that turns our expectations on their head, paired with genuinely affecting performances, makes "Game Changers" one of the sweetest comedies of the year.

—Caralynn Lippo, Entertainment Editor

John Stamos does his usual thing in "Big Shot," but he does it so well. We'd love to see him get some Emmy love for the role.

John Stamos does his usual thing in "Big Shot," but he does it so well. We
Stamos is in peak Stamos form in "Big Shot."      Disney/Gilles Mingasson

Does John Stamos play versions of the same character in almost everything he's in? Yes. Does he do it extremely well? Also yes.

Stamos gives a great comedic performance as Coach Marvyn Korn, with some tender moments that took us completely by surprise — in a good way.

—Debanjali Bose, Associate Editor

Victoria Pedretti deserved a nomination for "The Haunting of Hill House" and she doubly deserves one this year for "The Haunting of Bly Manor."

Victoria Pedretti deserved a nomination for "The Haunting of Hill House" and she doubly deserves one this year for "The Haunting of Bly Manor."
Eike Schroter/Netflix

Pedretti's Dani takes viewers through the full gamut of emotions right up until her devastating ending.

Her role in the "Hill House" follow-up is deeper and far more nuanced than we expected going in (come for the scares, stay for one of the best TV romances of the year). And Pedretti knocks it out of the park.

—Caralynn Lippo, Entertainment Editor

T'Nia Miller is another breakout, Emmy-worthy star as Hannah Grose in "The Haunting of Bly Manor."

T
Tahirah Sharif (left) as Rebecca and T'Nia Miller as Hannah on "The Haunting of Bly Manor."      Eike Schroter/Netflix

"Bly Manor" delivered one of the best TV episodes of the year with its Hannah Grose-centric episode five, "The Altar of the Dead." It's a mind-bending and terrifying exploration of Hannah's past, ultimately revealing the heartbreaking (and frankly disturbing) truth about the manor's housekeeper.

Miller makes us feel every ounce of anguish that Hannah does in her award-worthy performance.

—Caralynn Lippo, Entertainment Editor

Omar Sy is captivating as a gentleman thief in Netflix's hit, "Lupin."

Omar Sy is captivating as a gentleman thief in Netflix
Omar Sy keeps us glued to our screens in "Lupin."      Emmanuel Guimier/Netflix

There's a reason why "Lupin" is one of the most watched shows on Netflix — Omar Sy is that reason.

We can't look away as Sy dons dozens of disguises to play Assane Diop, the gentleman thief with a grudge to settle. His captivating performance transcends language in this French series.

—Debanjali Bose, Associate Editor

Elizabeth Olsen could break through the Emmys' shut-out of superhero TV with her gripping, emotional performance as Wanda Maximoff in "WandaVision," but we're a little nervous about her odds.

Elizabeth Olsen could break through the Emmys
Elizabeth Olsen broke our hearts several times over in "WandaVision."      Marvel Studios/Disney Plus

Elizabeth Olsen delivers a brilliant deep dive into how we process grief on "WandaVision."

If you watched the show going in blind, you likely didn't realize you were watching a series about loss under the guise of a Marvel comedy until the curtain was lifted episodes later, making Olsen's performance all the more heart-wrenching as Wanda's mental health continues to deteriorate by the show's end.

Olsen's nuanced performance is worth a rewatch to uncover slight hints she gives along the way at the trauma and pain Wanda worked so hard to ignore behind a fake facade of a television comedy.

—Kirsten Acuna, Entertainment Correspondent

READ MORE ARTICLES ON

Advertisement