The 25 best pies in America, ranked

24. Peach blueberry pie, Fredericksburg Pie Company, Fredericksburg, Texas

"...The peach blueberry — the BEST CRUST EVER, offering the perfect texture and flakiness. The fruit was perfectly sweet." - Yelp user Jenny L

23. Caramel apple pie, Pie Snob, Phoenix, Arizona

"Before Pie Snob, I was not even a pie person, but for some reason I wanted to have a pie at my Thanksgiving, so we ordered the caramel apple. Needless to say, it was the best pie I have ever had in my life. We order one for every Thanksgiving, every Christmas, and any time family comes out. Truly amazing." - Yelp user Jessica W

22. Crack pie, Sweet Dogs, Miami, Florida

"The owner first got to me when he offered me a bite of the crack pie before I had even placed my order. I was sold right then and there. The crack pie must really have something illegal in it because I promptly paid for two." - Yelp user Joann C

21. Strawberry rhubarb pie, Maui Pie, Maui, Hawaii

"I know for sure we had the Strawberry Rhubarb and Raspberry Peach pies, which were incredible. Their crust is crisp, sweet and crunchy, while the filling is just bursting full of fresh fruit!" - Yelp user Sean C

20. Crack pie, Momofuku Milk Bar, New York City, New York

"The pie is to die for. As I took a bite, I knew instantly that there's like a pound of butter in that one slice of pie, but it's so good that I didn't care. It was so good that I went back to buy an entire pie to bring home back to Chicago." - Yelp user Patty C

19. Chocolate pretzel pie, Coconuts, Fort Lauderdale, Florida

"Do not miss the chocolate fudge pie on top of a pretzel crust for dessert. One bite of that thing and I knew I would definitely be back to Coconuts." - Yelp user Henry A

18. Pumpkin Pie, CRAFTkitchen, Henderson, Nevada

"All of the mini pastry selections (pumpkin pie, pecan pie, carrot cake, and tiramisu) were all excellent! And beautifully presented as well." - Yelp user Deborah J

17. Key lime pie, Chelsea's Kitchen, Phoenix, Arizona

"The key lime pie ($8) is to die for and this wasn't the first time we've had this 'must have' dessert!" - Yelp user Greg G

16. Gluten-free whoopie pie, Wildflour Vegan Bakery and Café, Pawtucket, Rhode Island

"Yes, it's vegan, but the things they make force you to question why you haven't been eating vegan baked goods all along. The granola scone, chocolate-peanut butter brownie, and the whoopie pie are in 'god-tier' status when it comes to bakery treats. " - Yelp user Allan P

15. Apple pie, Baked and Wired, Washington DC

"I'm usually more of a cupcake guy, but this apple pie kills it." - Yelp user Todd M

14. Pumpkin chiffon pie, Summer House Santa Monica, Chicago, Illinois

"Had an amazing dinner experience here... The braised short ribs and chiffon pumpkin pie were outstanding!" - Yelp user Noreen H

13. Apple Pie, Pie Bar, Seattle, Washington

"I kid you not, THE BEST APPLE CRUMBLE PIE I'VE HAD! (And I've had great pies before!) The filling was not too sweet and the apples were not too tart. The crumble topping was the most perfect topping you can imagine." - Yelp user Michelle D

12. Key lime pie, Breadman Miami Bakery, Hialeah, Florida

"Great Bakery! Try it all, then come back and do it again. Should have option for more stars." - Yelp user Michael P

11. Pecan pie, East Bay Coffee Company, Pinole, California

"Hands down the best local coffee shop in Pinole! Great coffee, desserts, spacious ambiance, and friendly baristas." - Yelp user Jenna R

10. Apple pie, Maui Sugar Shop Bakery, Lahaina, Hawaii

"Oh man, come here! Everything is so delicious and all gluten-free! I was in heaven! And the staff was so friendly. " - Yelp user Sarah P

9. Banana cream pie, swah-rey, Saint Petersburg, Florida

"I had the banana cream pie in a glass and it was the perfect size, wonderful taste, and left me feeling satisfied, but not full." - Yelp user Nicole D

8. Coconut cream pie, Jean-Marc Chatellier's French Bakery, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

"I'll eat anything that comes out of this bakery, but my absolute favorite is the banana cream pie and coconut cream pie." - Yelp user T Y

7. Banana cream pie, Freedom Bakery & Confections, Watsonville, California

"The banana cream pie is AMAZING. You must try it! The the whipped cream is so light, the banana cream is super rich and, well, creamy, and the crust is golden, flaky, and delicious!" - Yelp user Vanessa Q

6. Boston cream pie, Cafe Valer, West Covina, California

"I love this place because of the variety of items they have; not to mention the delicious desserts they offer... Prices are reasonable and service is great." - Yelp user Yooneek A

5. Coffee pecan pie, OMG! Dessert Lounge, Anaheim, California

"Found this gem on Yelp after a hefty meal... I sampled the coffee pecan pie and it's sooooo good!" - Yelp user Abigail E

4. Ozark berry pie, Paradise Point Cafe, Cottonwood, Arizona

"Just one bite of the berry pie is an explosion of berry goodness! This hard-working baking duo take great pride in their work and the results are... a slice of happiness." - Yelp user James G

3. Pecan pie, Butter Cake Shoppe, Los Feliz, California

"Purchased two pies — pecan and bourbon pumpkin — for Thanksgiving dinner... The Pecan pie was a big hit with family." - Yelp user Robert G

2. Gelato pie, Gelatology, Las Vegas, Nevada

"... Most of the guests/hosts at the friends-giving event were delighted to try the gelato pie! It had the right amount of sweetness (no diabeetus!) with small tidbits of rosemary..." - Yelp user Mawa G

1. Key lime pie, Sweet Delights, Miami, Florida

"Best pie I have ever had in my life! The owner and only worker and creator of these amazing key lime pies, Mrs. Debbie, is the nicest, most amazing person I've ever met!" - Yelp user Christopher Z