The
Laura Mercier Caviar Sticks have it all — versatility, ease of use, and a longlasting, budge-proof formula.
The top-rated cream eyeshadows according to Rank and Style (plus more than 3,000 Sephora shoppers) are Laura Mercier Caviar Sticks and after trying them myself, I understand why.
These creamy, blendable eyeshadows come in a stick format, so you don't have to get your fingers or a brush dirty. Plus, the color selection is wonderful. While there aren't as many super-bold shades, the lineup features unique duo-chrome metallics, shimmery jewel tones, and mattes with dimension. Since most cream eyeshadows focus on sparkle, I love that this range includes seven mattes in shades like pale pink, taupe, and gray. My personal favorite shade is Amethyst.
These promise to be budge-proof, meaning they won't transfer or crease. They stayed put on my lids, but I found them to be a little stiffer when applying than other formulas, though they're still creamy. However, if you have oily lids, I'd recommend using primer first.
The domed tip can be used in hard-to-reach places like along the lash line or inner corner, as well as all-over color. I typically swipe directly onto my lid and blend out toward my crease with a fingertip or fluffy brush.
As Allure points out, "The buttery formula sets in about a minute and then stays put for hours," so work fast. It's also given Laura Mercier Caviar Stick in "Tuxedo" a Best of Beauty award two years in a row.
"I love this product. I have limited time in the morning and this is incredibly easy to use. Use as a liner, or eye shadow. Easy to blend. Then it stays put," writes one Sephora reviewer.
Pros: Wide color selection, three finishes, longlasting, easy to use
Cons: Expensive, might set too quickly