REUTERS/Kevork Djansezian
After the public recoiled in disgust, Gibson did the revealing interview apologizing for the comments and has met with Jewish leaders. In 2007, a judge even praised him for his progress in his alcohol rehab. But the actor who was a sex symbol in the 1980s and went on to direct in the '90s (and make one of the most profitable movies of all time, "The Passion of the Christ") has never rebounded since that summer evening.
Gibson has starred in only six films since 2006 (including one that's coming out this summer, "Blood Father"). And not a single one with a big studio backing it.
Shane Black - who is the director of the new movie "The Nice Guys" and wrote one of Gibson's most legendary moments, "Lethal Weapon" - thinks he knows why the actor has received a lack of work.
"I think he's essentially been blacklisted in the industry," Black told Business Insider in a new interview. "I think people don't want to work with him."
Pascal Le Segretain/Getty
In fact, Downey Jr. told Black a while back that he'd like Gibson to direct an "Iron Man" movie if another one happens (Black directed "Iron Man 3").
But Black says there's been no word since, and as far as he knows, the idea of Gibson helming "Iron Man" is "nothing serious."
Black is no stranger to substance abuse, either. He's been open about his hard-partying ways in the 1990s and his battle to get sober in 2008.
And as someome with his own struggles, Black believes Gibson needs to be forgiven.
"I've always been a tremendous fan of Mel Gibson, not just as an actor, but I think he's a good guy," Black said. "I just don't believe in holding anyone accountable for something that they say while they're drunk because if I'm drunk I'm going to be deliberately belligerent, first off. I'm going to say something that I know will piss you off and will delight in the fact that I'm destroying the house and burning it down. That's what drunk people do. So the idea that that's truly who a person is when he's had a few, I don't believe that at all. I just think that's wrong. I know a lot of great people and they are not necessarily great when they're drunk. So I don't trust that."
Gibson is currently in postproduction on his first directing effort in a decade, the World War II drama "Hacksaw Ridge," starring Andrew Garfield. The Gibson we knew may never get his full comeback, thanks to the "nasty things" he said that night with the cops, as Black puts it. But he's getting somewhere.