I tried this gorgeous Surface Pro alternative, and it showed what's wrong with tablet PCs

It’s not hard to see the iPad influence here, but that’s far from the worst thing to take after. The metallic back is smooth and solid, with few flourishes and no creakiness. The bezels aren’t big, the edges are nice and chamfered, and the volume and power buttons have a satisfying click. There’s a clean, professional feel to the whole thing that invites you to show it off.

That’s helped by how light and thin it is. At 0.27 inches thin and 1.4 pounds, the MateBook is a breeze to carry around, and no burden at all in your bag. It’s way more “tablet” than “detached laptop screen.”

The only real complaints I could see are the lack of a rear-facing camera, just a decent 5-megapixel selfie cam, and the lack of a Start menu key on the tablet’s front. I can’t save you if you’re someone who uses a tablet to take pictures, but you can get around the latter with the MateBook’s keyboard case.

It’s not bad, just unspectacular. The keys themselves are big, but barely spaced out, and they hit down with more impact than I’d prefer.

I still prefer it to the mushiness of Apple’s Smart Keyboard for the iPad Pro, but it’s not as fast or gentle as the board on a hybrid like Lenovo’s ThinkPad X1 Yoga.

The mousepad, meanwhile, responds to clicks, gestures, and general movements just fine. It’s not buttery smooth, but it didn’t cause any complaints.

Here’s the first of a few red flags here. As noted above, devices like this are tablets first, laptops second. Though the MateBook does well to stay locked into its connector above the keyboard, there’s still no hinge holding everything together. Instead, per usual, the cover folds back and props the tablet up magnetically.

Here, you can rest the device at two angles. The wider of those two, though, takes very little force to fall apart. Press it just a bit, and the display falls flat.

This isn’t a totally unique problem, but it makes the MateBook difficult to use in most places that aren’t a desk. Browsing around in bed, for instance, I usually kept a pillow behind the display to ensure it stayed up. It’s hard to be much of a laptop when you aren’t really made for people’s laps.

Still, it’s perfectly sturdy at its other, more upright angle. And if you do get most of your stuff done at a desk, you can get used to things easily enough. It’s just the fact that you have to “get used to” anything that’s the problem.

If you’re looking to the MateBook for more involved work, you’ll need to add that connectivity through a docking station. Huawei’s own MateDock adds HDMI, USB, Ethernet, VGA, and a goofy name, but it’s sold separately.

Related to that, Huawei’s also got a “MatePen” stylus. It feels nice, works fine, and has a built-in laser pointer. Chances are you’d already know if you need something like that.

It's a 12-inch IPS LCD screen, with a more-than-sharp-enough resolution of 2160x1440.

Although its colors don’t pop as much as they would on a good OLED panel, they’re still pretty vivid, and everything can get good and bright if needed. It does skew a bit on the bluish side, so it’s not totally accurate, but you’ll only really notice that if you’re looking out for it.

My bigger complaint is that it catches too much glare to be comfortable in the sunlight.

But taken as a whole, it does much more right than wrong. It presents no issues as a touchscreen, either.

If you’re curious, my review unit came with an Intel Core m5-6Y54 processor, 8GB of RAM, and 256GB of flash storage. Cheaper models can bump that down to a weaker Core m3 CPU and 4GB of RAM.

That Core m chip is what allows the MateBook to be so thin, and for most needs, it should be fine. You can open a bunch of tabs, do word processing, and stream video without things going haywire. Since it lets the MateBook be totally fanless, it also makes no noise as you go along. It’s stronger than your typical Chromebook, to put it one way.

It still falls short of the Core i chips you’d find in a Surface Pro or many full-on laptops, though. Apps and webpages take a bit longer to load, and you’ll want to steer clear of any gaming or involved photo editing. The back of the device can also get fairly hot if you push it too hard.

Without getting too deep into the technical weeds here, Huawei’s also partitioned that 256GB SSD in a way that isn’t totally efficient, so transferring files is relatively sluggish too.

But again, for most of the things people do with their laptops, it’s solid. Just understand you’re trading power for slimness.

The MateBook technically starts at $699, but you can throw that out, since its specs are too weak, and since it doesn’t include the keyboard case. For something competent, you’d want the 8GB of RAM in my $999 model, then add on the keyboard for another $129. Then you’d have to pay a little more if you wanted more than one port. (Huawei’s goes for $89.)

At that price, I’d just suggest going all out for the stronger and (much) longer-lasting Surface Pro 4 — if you need a tablet that at least comes close to being your PC. For $1100-1200, though, you can find a handful of laptops that are A.) convertible, B.) thin, and C.) not going to make you contort to use them.