3. (TIE) Cocobay Resort-Valley Church, Antigua

Hotels.com average guest rating: 4.6/5

Price: From $387/night

Cocobay is one of the smaller resorts on this list and feels more like a boutique hotel. Its pastel cottages sit on the hill above Coco Beach, overlooking the Caribbean Sea. Some of the more expensive cottages come with their own private plunge pools.